From the Berlin Football Daily
The windows closed, what’s the grade? A look at BFC Dynamo, by Karl Hausser
BFC Dynamo have built up a reputation this past ten years as the “Little Team That Could”. From a RegionalLiga club with poor finances that were compounded by an inexplicable decision by management at the time to build a new stadium, to a 3. Liga and Bundesliga 2 club whose finances were a bit more secure but whose spending was always on the thrifty side, many fans were hoping that after they survived their initial foray into the Bundesliga the club would turn around and start reinvesting some of their newfound riches, especially as it appears the club is trying to transition itself from being a stepping stone club to one players will want to join and stay long term. Supplementing these players would be those found by the clubs scouting department, one which is very under rated by others in this reporters opinion. The club has always been careful in the transfer window, and what risks they have taken in the past have been well calculated and prepared.

OUTS
If there is one thing to be said in the clubs defense, it is that they received value for every player sold, especially in the case of Dragan Pavlovic, as Sheffield’s numerous attempts to unsettle the player and club by not meeting his contracts release clause were turned aside and he ended up leaving for €24.5M.
And with Pep Guardiola and Tottenham making it known that Aleksandar Petrov was their primary target,, the young Bulgarian striker leaving for €74M is a very good deal for both teams.
Lamine Injai and Gabrijel Rukavina were key to the club getting promoted, but it has been apparent for a season at least that the Bundesliga is a step beyond their capabilities. Mohammed Mehri, an early success story of the Dynamo youth system product, is a very good example of how to conduct oneself on and off the field, but if we are to be honest his only season as a started in the Bundesliga was so bad he didn’t see the bench for the next two seasons. Although some domestic clubs were interested, he preferred to move back to Iran, to be closer to family.
Abdelkader Nasri was part of a crowded midfield, but the Algerian international had obviously made a big enough impression on RB Salzburg that they made an unsolicited €7.5M offer, one that was quickly accepted by the club. Given the depth the team has at the positions Nasri plays, losing him would not be a big concern, but BMG swooping in to get Vladimir Camara to join for €7M makes one of the clubs strengths a question in the reporters opinion.
Matteo Anelli could not adapt to Coach Schmidt’s offense, and his performance in the league last season was marred by the numerous yellows, one red card, and several defensive mistakes that if he had stayed, would ensure he would not see a lot of playing time. He asked to leave, and Dynao agreed, helping facilitate the move to Salernitana.
Several players also left on loan, many in an effort to get them more playing time to develop. Clermonts offer for Mpho Mathenjwa was at first rebuffed, until the striker told them he would prefer to play in France and develop some more, Clermont stepping up to cover more of the players salary certainly helped as well. Fan favorite Sebastiano Esposito left on loan to Motherwell, and given this is the last year of his contract it is highly unlikely we will see him in Dynamo Red and Brown again. While his first two seasons in the Bundeliga with the club were very solid, the devestating hip injury he suffered last season has clearly robbed the young Italian of a step, and with several promising youngsters behind him, there was little guarantee he would see the pitch here in Berlin.
The deadline deal for Sergio Gonzalez took everyone by surprise. The promising young Chilean international had transitioned quite well to his role as a D(c), and had already performed quite well in the first four games of the season. Dynamo may have been able to fight of Stefano Pioli’s first offer, but once Gonzalalez’s release clause was met, there was little Dynamo could do to keep the talented youngster from leaving.

INS:
The expected spending spree however, has yet to occur, but that just means Dynamo has been doing “Dynamo Things’ as fans like to say. Scout hard, scout often, spend wisely. And in this reporters opinion, for the most part, they have.
Day 1 of the Transfer window opening signing Antonio Borani and Roger Puigvert are youth players with potential, whether or not they reach that is up to them, but they are both in the “Low Risk – High Reward” category. More intriguing is the signing of young Malian international Defensive Back Mantene Sountoura, who brings an intriguing set of skills to the table, and who development potential is very high in many peoples opinions.



Iaccopo Zappasodi, Mounir el Ouassli, Josue Levy and Gilberto Olivera are all low risk signings by the club, signed to fill needs at depth and to bring compeition to positions. Of those four, El Ouassli will probably see the most playing time this year ion the midfield, the Algerian DLP by way of Porto brings a very deft touch, good passing technique and ball control skills to the pitch. Keeper Olivera is solid enough between the sticks, but I am not sure he is an upper tier sort of keeper. However should something happen to young Jakov Popovic, the young Croatian international who will mostly likely be Pavlovics successor, Olivera should be able to hold the line. The Young Belgian Keeper is capable, and I do not doubt the team would win games with him wearing the gloves, but I also do not think he is the long term answer in goal.




The clubs first big money signing of the window left many, including this reporter, in shock. Mirko Tulli, the young…mecurial forward had signed with Inter from Cremonese to be a starter, but with Nicolas Jackson, Wahid Faghir and Goncalo Ramos having a lock in Simeone’s 5-3-2 formation, Tulli was often left on the bench, eventually falling out with the club. Tulli is a talented player, anyone with a modicum of football knowledge can see that, but Inter’s demands for the youngster were sky high, pricing him out of most teams budgets, and Inter went even further by not allowing the youngster to go out on loan. Things finally came to a head at the end of the 31/32 season, when Tulli announced he would not resign a new contract with the club, leaving on a free. Inters initial transfer fee was still sky high, but once the club realized the price they put on the player was keeping him in Milan, where he would soon leave on a free, they lowered their asking price, and the offers came flooding in.
Noone expected him to sign with Dynamo, and after he did, noone expects him to stay beyond the January transfer window of next season. Why did Tulli sign with Berlin and not one of the other 20 plus teams chasing after him? If his comments after the contract signing are to be believed:
“Coach was honest with me. How could I tell? Let me tell you, after listening to everything that REDACTED REDACTED Simeone said to me my five years in Milan, I know when a person is telling me the truth and when they are REDACTED Lying. Coach Schmidt and I met, he said ‘Petrov is going to sign with Tottenham, for big money. I need a forward who can score goals, be professional on and off the field, and start at least 30 games for me this season. You go out, you do that, maybe a bigger team comes after you, and if you want to leave, fine. But be a good player, be a good teammate, and everything will work out. You do right by me, I will do right by you.’ That REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED REDACTED Simeone, 5 years he tell me “You will be doing this, you will be playing here, scoring from there, when I am not getting splinters in my REDACTED from sitting on the bench, Simeone is down one one knee kissing my ass making me promises with his sweet REDACTED talk, and I’m sorry, you want to REDACTED Mirko, you need to buy me a good dinner with some good REDACTED wine first. Coach Schmidt, treated me like a player, and a man. I REDACTED REDACTED respect that.”

Ognjen Vojvodic is the sort of player Coach Schmidt loves to sign: versatile, capable, and fairly cheap given this years market. The Serbian Defensive back will see a good amount of playing time this year.

American International Christian Doughty is the tall, imposing aerial defender Palace has been lacking these past couple of seasons. After signing with Palace the Florida native could never crack the starting lineup, but with the likes of Anderson, Kristensen, and Nelsson there, it’s easier to understand why. Dought did get plenty of playing time in other competition, a loan spell at Bristol City was good; but it was his spells at Braunschweig and Schalke from 29-31 that put his on most Germans radars, including Coach Schmidt.
Leo Marques is likewise another player that checks off many of the things Coach Schmidt likes, the Portugeuse defender can play either side opf the defense, and while I wish he would be a little more aggressive in his playstyle, he is still a very solid defender.
Fabio Neiva from Braga is a very similar player, except he is more versatile in the positions he can play. The young Portuguese international appears to have a very high ceiling, one which Dynamo could help him reach should they exercise the €4.5M optional fee in his loan agreement.

The signing of the offseason however, may be the one player that has been overlooked by many, and that is the young Ecuadorian AM(C) Carlos Tenorio. The player was signed and immediately loaned back to Alianza to finish the season there, but it appears that the BFC scouting department has once again found a diamond in the rough who could develop into one of the better Advanced Midfielders out there.

All told, BFC has sold €130M and bought €54M worth of players. On paper, is the club better? Yes. On the field, that remains to be seen. For the most part, many of the player moves are swaps: Petrov for Tulli, Camara for Doughty, and so on, but in spending that much money, even taking into account what and whom they sold, unless they finish as high or higher than they did last season, will it have been worth it?




































































