The Kids Are Alright -Season 7

European Dreams…Because Conference League is still Europe

After a 3 Month delay, I blame missed payments to contractors, the new Stadium is finally open.

It’s a lovely stadium, there’s room for growth in the future, I couldn’t be happier with it. I also couldn’t be happier with the board, who waited until we were financially stable enough to pay for the thing. Unlike my board in my FM23 save…


Looks can be deceiving:

This looks impressive, until you realize as a Youth Only squad, at least 16-17 of our players are getting playing time here, and then there are all the players we have let go to other squads in country.

Transfer wise, it was a quiet year. I alluded to it in my previous post on the save, this and the next few years are going to be interesting in terms of player we move and player we keep. The two are not mutually exclusive, because I know in the future there will be player we want to keep but can’t.

We are at the point now where players who aren’t going to be on the squad I am more than happy to sell to teams in Country, especially if they can help the squad. There are no real surprises here, although I had Radu graded pretty high in the Class of ’27, his true colors soon revealed him to be middling at best.

As I expected/feared, who to let go and who to keep has been turning into quite the guessing game, especially with regards to squad death. It’s one thing to have a dearth of 5 Star PA players, its another when they are all in the same positions. As an example

Rotariu was my first choice to be the keeper of the future. He’s averaged about 8 starts a season, but I killed his development when I sent him on loan to CSM Deva and he started all of 11 games. Last year he started 13 and allowed 22 but had 5 shutouts. This year he had 15 starts and allowed 17 with 6 shutouts. He still has room to improve, but Vasiliu and Alexandru already have better GK related attributes, and of those two Alexandru is the better option, for now. But what if Alexandru is close to topping out? Can I afford to play Vasiliu? Rotariu isn’t going to get appreciably better IMO, but we need to balance giving the youngsters playing time while doing moderately well in the league. Luckily, there are loan options available, and I sent Alexandru out. The good news was that he was Hermannstadt’s starting keeper all season, with 29 games played, allowing 56 with 4 shutouts and 2 POM’s. It wasn’t enough to keep them from the drop, but if you were to see his defense, you would understand why he went out with two stars and came back with three. Barbu we will talk about more later, he’s from this years intake, but it looks like next year it’s going to be Tiberius as the First Choice, with Rotariu as the backup, if he stays.

This is just the keepers though. It’s becoming a fun problem to have in other positions, and it really does force you to spend some time looking at how players have developed over the season. In the past, with the Spreadsheet, that was easier to do. Attribute-less, its a lot more diving into data, and I like that, its one of the reasons I switched to the skin.


We started the season off on the right foot:

Our only Liga I loss happened at Sepsi, although to be honest we should have lost at Petrolul Ploiești, but the we also should have won at Craivoa and Arad. Hlinca has really improved since he started getting regular playing time:

Remember, 1-7 is Red, 8-12 is Orange, 13-16 is Blue and 17+ is green.

As we can see, he started out as a player who was at best near the top of Average, and now he is solidly Good, especially with the improvements in both his Physical and Attacking Attributes. He’s probably one of the better forwards in Romania, and considering he’s homegrown, that’s saying quite a bit, especially when you consider other teams are bringing in players like this:

On a FREE. From Cercle Brugge. But I digress…

One of the areas I was hoping to improve this year was in the Cup. The past couple of seasons we have either been left on the outside looking in or just blowing it, October is a pretty congested month, but one of the newer benefits we have is a decent amount of depth, so I feel more comfortable rotating the side against the lower league teams.

Another good run of games for us, including some very good wins against Dinamo, revenge against Petrolul Ploiești, and some questionable defense against Botoșani. In our Cup group we finished in 1st place on 11 points, which is quite good considering we we have finished in the past.

Our Cup ambitions came to a crashing halt against Craiova.

I went on the attack at the start of the second half, and we broke thru in the 62nd and equalized in the 77th minute, but before I could even set the instructions to protect the lead they scored. I swear I saw all my pixel players just sag on themselves.

We were flying high. The problem is Farul, Rapid Bucaresti and Cluj are all flying a little bit higher, but we entered the split in the Playoff Group. But before we got down to those games, the Youths arrived.

I have to remember this is ‘their’ definition of a ‘Golden Generation’. There are really, unless I am wrong, Four players to look at

Barbu, as we saw above, joins an already deep pool of Keepers. I think he’s one of those players whose ‘On The Cusp’ in a lot of attributes, where his GK Reactions are at least an 8, but I think they are closer to 12. Getting him playing time will be interesting, we need to get another affiliate, but I am willing to give him a shot.

Sergiu Fieraru. I am not sure why, but something tells me that Fieraru is not going to get much better than this. But that I mean he’s probably around a 80 CA player, and is going to top out at 90-95 no matter how much training or game time he gets. That said he’s a solid player, but I don’t have high hopes for him, especially if we want to grow as a club domestically.

I think Alexandru Dumitrache could be better than Fieraru, but the ‘Unambitious’ (Seriously WTF is up with this?) and the number of people in front of him is going to hamper him playing striker. What I may need to do is spend some time looking at training him and Fieraru in other positions. The good news is they are both already decent wingers as well.

Rareş Florea is the best of the rest, and I think he’s the opposite of Barbu, and all his orange attributes are probably 8 or 9. He has good First Touch, and Work Rate, but that’s about it. He’s going to really need ti improve the next few years on the II squad and on loan if he wants s shot at the starting XI someday.

All in All, a very ‘Middling’ Golden Generation.


We did a respectable job in the Playoff group, but as I mentioned before Farul was too far ahead to overcome. However, a 3 way race for 2nd Place developed, but our last two games kept us in 4th place overall on 55 points, while Bucharesti had 56 and Cluj had 57.

However…

Farul Constanţa won the Cupa României Betano, meaning the UEL 3rd Qualifying Round Match went to Cluj, and the UECL slots shifted down, meaning we are playing in Europe, starting in the 2nd Qualifying Round.

European. Football.

We will probably crash and burn but still, it’s a positive step forward for sure.

We had several very good performances, and more than a few of the youngsters are really stepping up.

Hlinca led the league with 25 goals. Matiş had a solid season, but it’s quite obvious he’s starting to fall off. Marincu had a solid season as well, but the first two surprises are Voicu (Class of ’26) and Vágó (Class of ’29) had very good seasons. That Voicu was primarily a bench player and was able to put those numbers up was very good to see. Neagu (Class of ’28) also had a solid season.

In a bit of surprise news:

And in some unexpected news:

Sure, the one save I am doing a Youth only save the board goes out, without my asking, and finds a senior affiliate who’s not really an affiliate for us…FML…

That said: EUROPEAN FOOTBALL!!! The next building block of many we need to to win it all. But I was quite happy with the season, it was already a success before we backdoored our way into the UECL.

Now how do I fix these Youth Intakes…

The Kids Are Alright -Season 6

I am not too worried about this…yet…

One of the thoughts lingering in the back of my mind since the start of the save is “What if we become to successful to soon?” In many saves this isn’t something to worry about, but in a Youth Save (for many teams anyways), it is because if you are at a smaller club, when you get good Youth players who perform very well early in their careers, teams with more, be it reputation, money, and the like, will come calling for them. And they will leave, because despite the fact you are a brilliant Head Coach, the clubs has good facilities, good finances, and a growing reputation, you do not have the name, brand, continental or worldwide recognition and reputation to keep those players local. Case in point: Darius Niculcea. Perhaps the best player from the ’25 Youth Intake, he was forced into the starting XI for a variety of reasons, and he performed very well. So well that Napoli came and offered us €500K. And since he’s left, he sat on the bench for a year, and then went on loan for half a season to Bari, where he was OK. Would he have been better of staying here for another year or two? Maybe.

But my point, and I swear I am getting to it, is that really good young players who leave early hurt the club more than they help. We need to be winning, we need Continental competition games not for the money, financially we are on very solid ground:

but we need the to increase our stature in the game. This leads to a cycle of good youth players coming in, helping the team to succeed, then leaving while their replacements may not be as good as they are. As a result, a short, rapid rise to small success becomes a long, slow gradual increase to modest success, and then glacial progress to great success.

This is going to be a long save I think, unless the FM Gods smile upon us and gift us not only with great Intakes, but great success as well. I don’t believe we have had a ‘Great” Intake yet (I don’t care what the game says) but we have had some good ones, and some good, solid players have started to shine. Like Marin Neagu, Class of ’28.

The one thing that has worked in our favor is that our success has allowed us to recruit better domestic based coaches, and our success, and lack of player related expenditures, has left us with healthy finances and a board willing to spend some of that money on things we need. Like a new stadium, which we should be moving into the summer of ’30. And Facilities Improvements:

My goal this season was to finish around 8th. There are a couple of reasons for this:

  • It avoids a Relegation Fight.
  • It outs us near the top of the Relegation Group.

Why is this important? Because in Liga I 7th thru 16th go into the Relegation Group. In that 10 team group, 9th and 10th are automatically relegated. 7th and 8th go to a Liga I/Liga II Playoff.

And 1st and 2nd Play for European Football:

The winner qualifies for the Final:

And because of the whole “Half Points, then Full Points, etc rules, you end up with tables like this:

It’s possible to finish 1st in ‘Overall’ points, but now ‘Win’ the League.

Yes, it makes my head hurt too…But the goal is “Mid Table”, in that we finish high enough in the relegation group to challenge for European Football. I Can just hear my first talk of the locker room.

“OK, we want to be good, but not too good, and by that I also mean we can’t be too bad either. OK? Sparkling Mediocrity, that’s what we are aiming for this season, got it?”

I think they listened a little bit too well.


I don’t know that I could get those results again if I tried. And it’s not like we were playing for the draw either, a few of those games we had to come back from a deficit. Răzvan Matiş is turning into quite a good AM(C) in the Asymmetrical formation we are playing, despite the fact he hates big games.

The two biggest surprises so far are Dumitru Hlinca (Class of ’27) and Răzvan Teodorescu.

Hlinca’s Attacking Attributes have all improved to at least 13+, as has his First Touch. And I suspect that those attributes that haven’t changed were most likely on the low end when he arrived, and are now at least a point higher. World Class? No. World of ‘Good for this level of Football’? Yes.

Răzvan Teodorescu was part of the Class of ’24, right before I took over. Attribute wise, for this level of football, he’s Bril. But…

That UNAMBITIOUS personality just….gah…The thing is, he had had close to double digit goals and assists the last couple of seasons (9/4, 9/9, and 8/7), and I bet if he were to be, I don’t know a little more DRIVEN, he’d be 12+ in each category. As it is, a lof of his passes are either the 1st or 2nd in the route to the goal.

So, we weren’t exactly flying high, but slow and steady. Ahead of us lay the dread days of October, and did we let them get to us.

82nd Minute goal for Botosani and their win. 83rd minute goal by Rapid Bucharesti for their win. Arad, 3 goals up after 25 minutes played. With our earlier result, there was a 3 way tie for our Cupa României Betano Group Stage:

This was not the midtable finish I was looking for….

The year ended, and then began again, about the way I expected. Unexpected was beating Farul, expected was Arad scoring in the 1st minute then parking the bus. The Loss at Bucharesti ensured we would not make top 6, and it was a big sigh of relief when we thumped Sepsi to finish in 7th place.


Meet the New Youth, almost the same as the Old…

Only six player from this years Intake Worth Talking about I think. And their personalities were all over the place again as well…

Mercenary isn’t a bad personality to have. It’s not a good one, either, but if we show our loyalty to and provide Costi Popescu with opportunities, we increase the changes he will stay with us long term. His lack of Fitness and Strength is glaring, but he is Quick, Agile, his Attacking Skills are pretty solid, as is his Technique. I don’t think he will be a Striker for us though.

Being Unambitious on the other hand, almost certainly guarantees Andrei Laszlo will never be as good as his PA. The same can be said for Răzvan Teodorescu, who despite his already good attributes could be even better if he were just Balanced. Andrei will be given opportunities though. How long and how many are up to him though.

Branimir Feti continues our streak of players with Low Determination. And that’s a shame, because he’s a very solid player even with a DET that is <7, and could be a very good DLP/Carrilero type of player. For the time being he’s merely “Meh”…I hope he can see what Răzvan Teodorescu is doing and act accordingly, but I’m not going to hold my breath.

Vasile Ion has the best opportunity to be the best player out of this group. Not because he has the highest PA, or because he has a ‘Fairly Professional’ personality, but because he can play 3 positions we have a need at. He will probably be the first to get a decent amount of playing time out of this group.

I think whatever hopes I put in Alex Tănase, he will fall short of them. I am pretty sure that all of his attributes are on the lower end of the scale and he lost a star from when he came in to when we signed him. His versatility might save him, his injury proneness and horrible Possession attributes probably won’t.

Doru Vancea actually gained a star from the Intake to when we signed him. He’s probably got the best CA of all the Youth players from this year, but that could mean his ceiling is not the much higher (comes in at 80, tops out at 100 sort of thing). He has DLP written all over him, whether he wants to believe it or not. I think he has the best long term potential at the club, maybe not as a full time starter, but definitely as a back up/ squad player off the bench.


Our relegation Group battle went almost exactly to plan.

We beat up the teams at the bottom, beat most of the teams we were supposed to beat, and didn’t have a lot of “unexpected results”. The game at Csíkszereda was a draw until the 89th minute (blast and damn), and I knew we were in for a long day at Rapid Bucharesti when the first goal was an own goal by Ilie Formagiu…that loss hurt us, but beating Sepsi put us at the top of the group, meaning we got to play Universitatea Cluj in the first Playoff Game.

While the Shot’s and On Target are similar, we were clearly the better team. It was frustrating not to get more than the one goal we had, although the 2nd goal looked like a winner until the woodwork jumped up and saved it. Four days later we played against Farul Constanţa at their house for the right to go the Conference League.

The bossed us, as much as any team can in a 1-0 Extra time goal victory. All of our Attackers were sub 6.7, and it was Vasiliu (Class of ’28) in goal that stopped it from being a route. How he ended up on a 7.1 is a bit mind boggling, seeing what he faced and stopped I think it should have been higher. But if we are being honest, Farul Constanţa is simply a better team. I have mentioned it before, but if this wasn’t a Youth Only save, we would be the New Farul, bringing in Youth Players from across the region, training them up at our impressive facilities, and moving them on for profit. Heck, they are loaning players in From places like West Ham to fill positions, we can’t do that. We made them earn it, and as trite as that sounds now, I’ll take it.

The League Table ended up thusly:

FCSB won the Cupa României, which is why they are going to the Europa League. But I will take a 9th place finish, now and for the next couple of seasons.

We had some very good performances this seasons as well, quite a few players I was hoping would take it up to the next level did, some more than just one.

Matiş getting 23 goals as an AP on Attack is quite good, but it’s Teodorescu’s 12 goals and 18 assists that stand out for me.

There were several good performances from the rest of the squad:

Hlinca is becoming the player we thought he could be, in fact he was a big reason Matiş was able to score as much as he did, Dumitru was constantly getting doubled teamed and drawing defenders away from Matiş. Voicu had a good season off the bench, Vago had 2 goals and 10 assists from the M(C) position, Purcea was solid at D(R). The only position I had real concerns about was at Keeper. We let Rareş Murariu go at the beginning of the season and he retired. Our best options for replacing him were Nicolae Rotariu (Class of ’23, before I arrived), Tiberiu Alexandru (Class of ’25), Ciprian “Low Self Belief” Şandru, (Class of ’27) and Adrian Vasiliu, Class of ’28.

For some reason, Rotariu has never grown above two stars. There could be reasons for that, the best is that as the club has gotten better, so has he, but as star rating are based on the players at your club, he’s grown with the rest of the squad but not gotten better. He started 15 games for us, and ended up with a 7.21 rating. The good news is we didn’t hear a lot about him doing bad things. The Bad news is we heard nothing about him doing good things. Alexandru went on loan to a Liga II Club, started 18 games and allowed 18 goals, and the club he went to was relegated…Sandru and Vasiliu are the same age, and while on paper Sandru is the better keeper now, I think Vasiliu will be the better overall keeper, which is why I gave him starts this season. Next season the job is his to lose.

I just hope my faith isn’t misplaced.

All in all, a good season. I think the days of relegation worries are behind us, and there are very few players from the original squad left. The question now is can we fend of those teams coming after a Matis or Dumitru, can our youth players develop accordingly, and can we possibly, maybe just do enough to get European Football?

The Kids Are Alright -Season 5

Out with the Old…

There is good and bad with a Youth Only Save, and depending on what your point of view is some issues can be both.

  • No Scouting to worry about, other than next opponents
  • No Transfers to worry about, at least coming in
  • Squad depth can be an issue
  • Sometimes you are forced to play bad players because you have no other option.

The list can go on, but for the moment, these are the primary issues, and to be honest the first two not being a factor means I am breezing thru seasons, because I am not spending time on scouting.

But we are five seasons in now, and that means most of the older players I have inherited have gone, sometimes against their will, and there are quite a few Youth Players starting/coming off the bench. What does that mean?

This:

I tend to be pretty…agnostic when it comes to formations. Do I have preferences? Yes. Am I going to try and fit my squad into those preferences? If it means I will not be hurting myself or the club in the long run, sure. On the other hand, in order to get my best players on the field, if that means I have to go with something a bit….different, I will.

Circumstances didn’t exactly force me into this formation, or it’s mirror, but the fact is this let me get my best players, established and up and coming, on the pitch, and if we are being honest, for me it’s been a solid formation. When it works, it works, and when it doesn’t it doesn’t.

These are the base instructions, and I tend to be more of a pregame/in game manager when it comes to making changes.

Speaking of Changes:

Voicu is in an interesting position for me, he’s a young player with potential in a position I have some pretty good younger players, and getting first team playing time here was going to be iffy, so we sent him on loan.

In the January transfer window, there weren’t a lot of surprises. Sporin had lost a couple of stars, I blame the scouting department, and he wasn’t going to see a ton of playing time here. The fact his Attacking and positional attributes did not visibly change also tells me that if he was improving during training and the Youth games, it wasn’t by a lot, and if the needle wasn’t moving by a lot, he was probably close to his potential.

Florin Ilie was part of a good D(C) rotation, but being primarily a D(R) he was a bit miffed when we didn’t play the asymmetric that suited him best. When Craiova came asking about him, he wanted to go. After negotiating, I think we got a fair deal for him.

Brădău is similar to Sporin, a player with potential who after three years of training and some spot starts was over taken by other players. I think he could be a decent squad player, but hje wanted first team playing time. I don’t know that he will get it at Iași, but he will probably get more time there than he will here.

Everyone else who left was either an earlier Youth Intake player with no future here, or an older player in the same boat.


Predicted to finish 15th with 600-1 odds, I knew we were better than that. I was aiming for mid table, top of the Relegation Group.

We had all of a week before Training started, and we got to work on the new formation right away, and it started to pay off immediately:

The 4-0 against FSCB was nice, and I was happy with the draw against Cluj until for some inexplicable reason one of their defenders fouled us in the box on a corner kick, and Matiş tucked it away for the last gasp win. The loss against Gloria Buzău was frustrating for several reasons. One is that my guys assumed that because they are recently promoted and are the other relegation pick, they are a bad team, and as a result put in a halfassed effort, the teams average rating without Murariu’s 7.2 is a 6.2. The secondis that they assumed they could turn it on when they needed to, and when they did Gloria Buzău counterattacked and scored their second goal, and would have had a 3rd if not for a brilliant save by our keeper. Losing at Farul Constanţa is not a bad thing, truth be told they are the team we could be if we were also able to do transfers, but as it stands they are about 5 years ahead of us in terms of Youth development, but we will get there. Eventually.

September was great. We had a long break, came back primed and rested for a busy October, 8 games in 24 days sort of busy, and promptly crapped the bed. The good news was that two of the three teams in our Cupa României group games were lower Liga, so I was able to play mostly rotated sides, but at the end of the day, the 3-0 loss to Argeş left us 3rd in the Group, tied with them on 10 points, and they not only had the goal differential but the head to head.

We went into the winter break in 4th place, thanks to only losing the one game against a U Craiova squad that if we are being honest, could beat you 3-1 or lose to you 3-1 depending on which version of their team shows up, and I was thinking it would be nice if we didn’t have to play in the relegation group. Of course, finishing the top of the relegation group mean you get a chance to play for European Football, I am not sure why, the Romanian Football Association does things its own way because they can apparently…but I was riding pretty high, our Youth Intake preview was good, and we had 9 players called up for International Duty. I was feeling good, the team was feeling good, our chances were good, so of course we did our best to throw it all away.

We could have lost every game in February, we probably should have, but with the draw at Voluntari and the win at Chindia, we clawed our way back into 6th place, and into the Champions Playoff Group.

And then came the good news of the save:

Not too shabby, especially when you consider that at this level of football, and compared to our squad, 5 star is probably 115 to 125 Ability, and you can go far with a team made up of those sort of players. On the other hand though:

That’s 8 Youth Players with Horrible Personalities. And I think I have seen more players with ‘Low Self Belief’ this save than I have in any other save since I started playing FM.

Vince Vágó, Florin Vlădilă, and Robert Chiseliţă are the best of a good bunch of players. Vágó is already on the high side of Average when it comes to his Physical and Attacking attributes, and while his Defending Attributes are on the lower side, his Possession Attributes more than make up for them. He has DLP written all over him, and if his Composure and Movement Attributes come up, he could be a mainstay in the midfield.

Tiberiu Alexandru, Class of ’25, is the next Keeper in waiting, but Florin definitely has first team potential. The problem is how do I get rid of this whole ‘Low Self Determination’ Issue. I could try and get him in a good mentoring group, but he also needs game time to improve, maybe a loan when he’s older will help?

If it weren’t for the Low Determination and Injury Proneness, Robert Chiseliţă could be a very good D(LC) His Physicals are already solid, as are his Defending Attributes. His Attacking and Possession skills are lacking, but what else do you expect from a 16 y/o kid? If some of those Movement Attributes come up, he could also be a capable DM

Of Eusebiou Iacob, Victor Niţă, Lennart Meyer and Robert Hexan, I think the one who doesn’t belong is Meyer. Yes, his starting attributes are nice, but he came in at 4 stars and is now a 3-4 star sort of player. The fact the has has a Balanced personality is more than a little salt in the wound, because I think what we see with him currently is what we are going to get. On the other hand, Robert Hexan is one player who I think will be better than he appears to be. Yes, the Low Determination is a killer, but his Physical and Defending Attributes are quite solid, and he’s also solid with regards to his Composure, Decision Making, Anticipation and Technique, plus he has the one thing you cannot teach: Height. at 6′ 4″ and 165 pound already, he’ll be on the bench at 17 getting some first team playing time. Maybe we can play him into a better personality.

The season finished out a little better than expected. Yes we finished at the bottom of the group, but with exception of the Cluj match, we played pretty well, even in our loses. The highlights were beating Farul, who finished 2nd overall, and getting our revenge on Cluj. Craiova, the League winners, beat us handily, but that’s not unexpected. We finished the season in 6th place overall, a long way from relegation, and quite a few youth players had plenty of quality playing time as well. As for the new formation (and it’s mirror), they worked out quite well.

51 goals from our top 4 attacking players is very nice, Matiş and Teodorescu also chipping in with 20 total assists is also very good. Dan Pureca, starting at WB(R) most of the season, made the most of his skills by chipping in 10 assists as well. Of the squad we inherited when we took over, only a few are left. Marincu, Pureca, Matiş and Murariu are the last, and Murariu is probably going to be leaving soon. Luckily we have several good candidates to replace him.

In other news our new stadium build is going well, the club is happy, the fans are happy, I do not expect to see any big changes this coming season, and to be honest I would not expect another top 6 finish. But I have been surprised before…

The Kids Are Alright -Season 4

“Custer had a plan too…”

Usually when do a more Youth Oriented save, I am at a club I am building up, there’s a decent amount of solid to good older players that will carry us forward, as as my youth progress from raw 15 and 16 year olds to 18 and 19 year olds with potential, they go out on loan or if they are good enough, they go onto the 1st Squad bench.

Here at Timişoara, I don’t have that luxury. While the older players I have are OK, there aren’t enough of them to carry the team forward, which means any youngster with potential not only gets first team playing time, they go right into the Senior Squad. There they not only get the playing time they need, they develop, and some have turned into players who are quite good. Like Darius Niculcea.

He’s easily the first good player we’ve had come thru the Youth Intakes, his first season as a part time starter he had 24(2) stars, with 1 goal, 3 assists, and 1 POM. Last season as the full time starter he 3 goals, 6 assists, and 1 POM, and both years he was selected to the Romanian U21 Squad.

So of course 5 games into the season Napoli offered 400K for him, I didn’t have a release clause on his contract, and he signed with the Italian club. They did offer him on loan back, and I accepted.

That’s how I am going to approach this going forward. If a club comes after one of my players, I am not going to ask for a loan back as part of the deal, but if they offer it to me, I’ll consider it. In this case Nicucea is the best D(R) I have, so I accepted it, an he went on to have 1 goal and 12 assists with us before leaving.


TRANSFER’S

Ursan, Păunescu, and Chivu are all Youth Players that I didn’t think were worth a grade, meaning 2 star potential or less. The fee’s for Ursan and Păunescu are based on future performances, and I doubt I will see them.

Zamfir (pan flute not included) was part of the Youth Intake the year before I took over, a defensive player who could play all 3 positions on the back line. He was decidedly average in all of them, and as a result did not get a lot of playing time. For whatever reason, Dinamo Bucureşti made an offer for him in the Spring Transfer window, and after debating whether or not to file a bug report, I took it. Who am I to stand in the way of a club making a bad financial decision? I’ve my own bad decisions to make. Chindia Târgoviște is a Liga II team, and to be honest if they are spending €100K on a middling winger like William Popoviciu, they aren’t getting promoted anytime soon IMO.


We are starting at least 4, and possibly5 players from the the ’25 Youth Intake. As I mentioned above, I don’t have the luxury of sitting them in the U19’s and waiting for them to develop, so they’re going to be starting. Yes, it’s Boys v Men, but it build character. 

That’s the slogan for the next few years: Construiește caracterul!

The goal is to avoid relegation. Acts of God aside, we aren’t finishing above midtable anytime soon, but avoiding relegation is an achievable goal. The question is how close to relegation are we going to be. My mantra has always been I am ‘mostly’ ok with losing, as long as we keep it close. I don’t know how long I can keep repeating that though.

There’s no middle ground. We’re either losing close, usually, or winning. The lack of draws is concerning. The low point was losing to a Liga II side in Hermannstadt in the Cupa României First Stage on penalties. Răzvan Matiş missed a PK in the 20th minute, then scored in the 117th to put as ahead, but the defense fell apart and they scored in the 120th…and then three of my guys missed their PK’s.

The first half opf the season was painful, but there were a couple of bright spots. Marius Marinescu started the season on two and a half stars, and at the midpoint he was up to Four. Along with 8 goals and 3 assists. Vasile Mihăescu, from the ’26 Intake, is starting at DM, and he’s improving, which is good. Goran Simedru, from the ’25 Intake, is also having a solid season at D(C).

As down as I was about some of our performances, at the half way point were were in 12th place with 16 points, and our goal differential was -6. One of the things in our favor was that both Gloria Buzău and Oţelul Galaţi have won 2 and 1 games respectively.

The New Year got off to a good start, as we did not lose until we played a very good FC Argeş squad, and our last loss before the League split was against last years winner Universitatea Craiova


Our Youth Intakes Are Officially Manic…

They are calling it a ‘Golden Generation.’ I’m thinking it’s 14 Karat Gold…

This is a screenshot of the best Youth Intake players to come thru this season:

  • 3 Unambitious
  • 1 Unsporting
  • 1 Low Determination
  • 1 Fairly Loyal
  • 1 Balanced
  • 2 Fairly Professional

This from a HOYD who is Professional. Next years had better be better than this…

Marin Neague is a pest of a winger, in that he’s all of 5′ 2″ and 100 pounds, but Physically speaking is good…except for the Strength. And Work Rate, and Balance. His Attacking and Possession skills are also average, but this is a good foundation to build from, assuming his Unsporting self wants to improve.

Paul Koszma is already pretty good on the Physical and Defending categories, and his Technique is also decent as well, but again, her Personality is going to be the biggest impediment to reaching his potential. 

Adrian Vasiliu is our 3rd (or 4th if you count the year I wasn’t here) 5 star potential Keeper. I do not know how much longer Rareş Murariu is going to be the starter, he made some noise about wanting to leave in the January window, but Adrian will be in the race to become the 1st Choice keeper. Of course, of the 5 Youth Keepers I have, 3 are Unambitious…

And I somehow missed 4 and 5 when nicknaming them…I’ll figure out a format, eventually.

Dan Secreteanu can play the left side of the pitch, but I think I am going to make him a D(L), maybe a wingback, as his attributes are already average in those areas. If his strength comes up, and some others as well, he could be a solid contributor for us.

Ilie Formagiu, 6’4″ 170 pounds at 15 YEARS OLD Ilie Formagiu, will start playing next year. Off the bench, unless he just bodies someone out of the way. Physically and Defending wise, he’s Average, but his Good Work Rate and Jumping, and his Excellent Bravery, should be an asset in Set Pieces. I think he has the best potential out of everyone who came in this Intake, now it’s up to me to not screw him up.

Dan Popescu…I am not sure what to think of him. Good Agility, Endurance, Quickness and Determination, average Possession skills, he has the potential to be a solid winger for us. But again, that personality…

I really want to like Armin Caraiman. They have him as a Target Forward, and from a Physical point of view, I can see that. His Attacking and Possession Attributes though…but in his defense, his personality is going to be an asset. If his Positioning and Concentration Improve, he might be a better DLP…

Lucian Ilie already had Good Technique, Fitness and Work Rate, but I am not sure how he would fare on the attack as a Mezzala. The good news is that Attribute wise, his is ‘Meh’ at every position except Roaming Playmaker, where he’s “Bleg!’ We will have to see where is in a couple of years…

Marian Tudor has the making of a solid DLF already, with Good Composure, Flair, Finishing and Technique. Aggressive as well, but I can’t help shake the feeling that what we see is pretty much what we are going to get. This is one time I wish I were wrong, but I am a fan of players with Determination, and the one thing we can stay about him is that he’s not…

Paul Freanţ could be a solid AM(C) if his physicals improve, if they don’t he will most likely be an M(C) in a CM/DLP sort of role. The problem is that’s a crowded position for us, and if he doesn’t stand out right away he might not get the playing time early. 

Thats going to be an ongoing theme with the save going forward, with a lot of depth, some of it potentially quality depth, in some roles, finding who is the best performer is going to be hard. 

But I didn’t choose this sort of save because it’s Easy. I chose it because I thought it was going to be easy…


We did more than enough to avoid relegation. Marinescu looks like the real deal, he’s been too consistent this year for me to believe otherwise, and we had some very solid performances across the board.

Matis had a solid season for us, but several teams are interested in him, and keeping him might be a detriment to the younger players in his position. Răzvan Teodorescu gives me hope that all my ‘Unambitious’ personality trait players will improve and be good, if not great for this level, of contributors

Oh, and the board has plans of it’s own as well it seems:

We beat the odds again, and I believe we have the makings of several quality younger players ready to step up and take over the next couple of year. The climb to the top is going to have some ups and downs, and a lot of plateaus as well, but I believe we are definitely on the way up. It’s going to be a slow process though, but one I am looking forward too.

I hope you all are looking forward to it as well, thanks for reading!

The Kids Are Alright -Season 3

The Glasses Just Make Me Look Smart…

I’m going to be 100% honest here: In game, I am about 10 seasons ahead of what I am posting. There are a couple reasons for this: 

  • I started this during the Winter break
  • Youth saves are very fast to play thru, especially when the time sink you enjoy, Scouting, isn’t a factor
  • I am having fun with it, and sitting down in the AM and logging off in the PM on a weekend realizing you just went thru four full seasons and aren’t exhausted is a good thing. Isn’t it?

That said, I still have no fricking clue how the Promotion/Relegation Groups in Liga I work, so lets see if we can figure this out now:

1st thru 6th Qualify for the Playoff Group.

7th thru 16th go to the Relegation Group.

Half points plus point plus carry the 1 and…..my head hurts. Seriously.

What I have learned is not only can you finish 1st in total points and not win the Liga, you can also finish last in points and not be relegated. For the teams at the very top and very bottom in a year where the points difference between them and their nearest competitor isn’t all that close, it doesn’t matter. 6 teams in the Championship group separated by 10 points? It matters…


This season was going to be brutal. The pundits picked us to finish 15th, and that was optimistic I think. I am pretty sure they are taking into account possible transfers, but without any of those coming in, were stuck with who we have, and who we have is a bunch of mediocre (for this level of football) players, and some potential. What we lack is a Striker, or three. Sburlea started for us last season, and was the very definition of ‘Meh’, and the available options I have aren’t any better. Brădău has the potential, but his personality is really holding back his development, and I think throwing a young, unproven striker into the fray in an effort to tray and stave off relegation is not a good recipe for success. 

So I went back to a 4-3-3-0 Strikerless.

The results were about what I expected.

My philosophy in situations like this is as follows:

  • Do not play to ‘Not Lose’
  • Draws are much better than losses
  • If you lose, try to make it close

The first half of the season, we were mostly successful in following that:

In a nutshell, we were losing to the teams who were most likely going to bet us, drawing the teams we had a chance with, and beating the teams we were supposed to beat, with few surprises really.

The draw and win at Craiova was nice, they have a very good squad. UTA Arad, Voluntari. Sepsi OSK are also strong, but the league is Farul Constanţa’s to lose. They are the club we aspire to be in a few years, Excellent Youth Facilities, Excellent Training Facilities, Exceptional Youth Recruitment, and Good Academy Coaching, and because FCSB lost so many players, including their best youth prospect, they aren’t running away with anything like they did the year before. The other good news was that our goal differential was not that bad either, and at the end of the year, we were in 9th place, with 19 points from 4 wins, 7 draws and 4 losses, with a -2 goal differential.

Our biggest issue was lack of offense. Sburlea had definitely fallen off, but young Răzvan Teodorescu, who I believe was in the Youth Intake the year before I joined, was having a solid season despite his Unambitious personality. Darius Niculcea had made the D(R) slot his to lose, and had also improved by quite a bit as well. We went into the break fairly confident we weren’t going to be in a relegation fight.

I am not sure it’s coincidental, but when the League splits in MArch into the two groups, that’s right around the time the Youth Intake happens. 

I thought going itno the New Year we may have had a chance to stay midtable, but 6 of our first 8 games were against teams at the top of the table, and it showed. I thought we would eke the draw out against Sepsi OSK, but they got two late goals quick. Winning two games and drawing FCSB was also nice, but we ended up in the Relegation Group, and that wasn’t a surprise.


A Decent Intake?

5 Elite Talents and 5 Good talents are nice, but what I am looking at are positions, and I am very satisfied with this intake. Another potential future keeper, two young choices at Striker, winger options, Midfielder options, this is a solid intake for us. We’re going to look at just the top 10.

The Best

Ciprian Şandru is the 3rd Youth Intake Keeper that has come across as 5 star Potential, and with Nicolae Rotariu (Another good young 5 Star Potential Keeper), that gives us 4 with talent. The question is which one develops first, and while my gut says Alexandru is going to be the best one of the bunch, I am going to rotate the others in as best I can and see how they do. Ciprian is already a solid young keeper, his attributes are a great foundation to build upon, and if his Keeper attributes increase accordingly, he can be a solid keeper at this level.

Radu Chirilă has a lot going for him. Already having good Endurance attributes, his Bravery and Balance are also good, and I suspect that most of his attributes that are in Orange would turn blue, if not for the fact he is Unambitious. Yes, he’s 4 1/2 star potential, but he has to want it, and his personality ensures that getting there is not going to be easy. At All.

Ionuţ Oltean is what I call a ‘Feast and Famine’ Youth. Where he is good, he’s actually pretty good. Where he’s bad, he’s very bad, and there’s not a whole lot in between. Unless his Attacking Attributes improve dramatically the next couple of years thru training and playing time, he’s not going to be a winger, but his lack of height and weight makes him an iffy midfield prospect IMO.

Of this years Intake, I am most happy with Dumitru Hlinca. Already having Excellent fitness, Good Flair and Technique, and with most of his other Passing Attributes already solid, he would be a great Targetman if he could jump and head, but as he can do neither of those, he’s going to be a DLF. His potentail may not be as high as the others, but he will be on the pitch before anyone else, because I need a decent striker up top.

Already 180 pounds and 6′ 6″ at 16, Eduard Nanu is a man among boys. Here’s hoping he’s not one of those player’s who is a “Look Like Tarzan, Play Like Jane!” sort of player. Physically he is already solid, and his Defending Attributes are solid as well, but I can’t help thinking as solid as he is now, he’s not going to get that much better.


The Better(ish)

Eduard Sevaciuc’s PA is based on a world where everything goes perfect. The fact his Physically lacking is something his Attacking and Possession Attributes might help cover up, but his lack of good defending attributes at this point means he would need to work hard to become a serviceable M(C)/DM. His casual personality all but ensures that will never happen.

From and Attribute standpoint, Dafin Ilie (II) and Remi Şurpanu are similar, and where one is lacking the other is good. Ilie has the best potential to be a full time starter IMO, rather he has the best chance because his lack of height, Injury proneness, and Unsporting Personality means he will most likely not get much better than he already is. Physically speaking, Remi is the better of the two, and he’s also better at all three center field positions…but his Personality is also dragging him down as well. I’d feel beetter about these 5 players if the personalities were anything in the middle of the pack, but this Casual/Unambitious/ stuff is just…awful…

Dan Dascălu has a solid foundation to build on. The question is what is he building? I think he could be a winger with about a 110-120 PA, which for this level of football is very good, but his Attacking Attributes would have to improve by leaps and bounds for that to happen. It’s it possible? Yes. Is it probable? I doubt it…

Last but not least, well mostly least, is Cristian Dumitrescu. He is definitely the first instance of “He looked so good from the stands, but on the pitch he’s mid.” I’ve seen. He came in at 3 1/2 stars potential, and now he’s 2-2 1/2. That tells me where he is now, he’s not going to get that much better without some help, and as yet another player with an Unambitious personality, he’s not going to utilize that help.

All told, not the best Intake really. This whole personality range is frustrating, as my current HOYD has a Balanced one, but the past 3 Intakes I’ve had ~15 Unambitious, ~4 Unsporting, a Low Self Belief, a Temperamental, and a Casual…yikes…


We were headed towards the Relegation playoff’s, then we thumped Petrolul 6-3, and drew our next to games to secure 12th place overall. We did just enough in the Relegation group to finish 5th, which put us above FC U Craiova, and they ended up being relegated because they lost in the Playoffs. But in the overall standings, they finished a place higher than us.

A reminder to not take the ‘post season’ lightly. 

Although, it could be worse, they could be UTA Arad, who finished 2nd overall but last in the Championship group, meaning they missed out on European football.


Performance wise, as one would expect from our finish, the team was average. No scorers in double digits, not assists in double digits, two of our best young players already out the door, and already some older players I am ready to move on as well.

I coached my 100th game, the board still hasn’t let me go on a coaching course, and while our finances are solid, we have to rent a new stadium to play in because the current one we are renting does not meet league requirements:

Next Season? I expect more of the same. This is that point where the older players I had when I took over the squad are going to start moving, some of them even if they don’t want too. The question is do I have capable replacements for them, and in many cases the answer is “We Shall Find Out.” As long as we don’t stumble, we should be fine. 

Should.

The Kids Are Alright: Season 2

Don’t Rock the Boat

As I mentioned previously, this is my second attempt at a ‘Youth Only’ save, the first was with a club in Croatia. In that save, we did not make it out of the 2nd Division, and as a result, the club went semi-professional. 2nd year we got promoted, the owners would not let us go pro, so the 3rd year we barely avoided relegation. 4th year we were still semi pro, and the Youth Intakes had not been good enough yet to produce any wonderkids that could help us, some solid talent but no ‘Good/Great’ Talents, and halfway thru the season, on a losing streak, the owners demanded 9 points from 6 games that included Dinamo Zagreb, Hadkuk Split, Rijeka, Rudes, and Slavan Belupo, and 4 games later I was shown the door. The kicker to all of this was that the club was secure in it’s finances, the decisions to go Semi Pro was made under the hood, and so were the following decisions to not go pro again. Did not being professional hurt us? Not as much as I wanted it to in hindsight, the one thing it really affected was training, as two sessions a week is not and never will be as good as seven sessions a week. And it could be some internal biases at play, but the Romanian Lower Leagues just seem to be more ‘solid’ than the Croatian ones. Then again, with as many lower leagues division as Romania has, maybe they should be.

The goal for this season was to improve on last season. Having finished 5th last season and losing in the Promotion Playoffs, improvement could mean a couple of things:

  • Finishing higher than 5th and get promoted
  • Finishing higher than 5th and NOT getting promoted
  • Finishing 6th and getting promoted.
  • Finishing 6th and NOT getting promoted.

Seeing how this save is going to take at least a couple of decades, I am OK with any of those results, as long as we finish top 6. What I am looking for this early in the save are continuing solid gameplay by my veteran players, improvement in the youth players, and improving the staff as we go along. Including me, as I currently have no coaching qualifications whatsoever.


CHANGES

We played a 4-3-3 Strikerless season because we had to, I felt that at the time we did not have any good options up top, and while it did the job for us, in that we made the playoffs and weren’t relegated, it lacked offensive punch.

I had a couple of options to play up top, and if we are being honest it was really a choice between “The Evil of Two Lesser’s”. At least that’s what I thought at the time. However, the transfer window hit, and that when things got very interesting.

Eventually losing Coperu and Duma is not a bad thing, as I think I have Youth Replacements for them. Aurel Vlaciu though, is a 19 y/o with 4 star CA and 4 1/2 star PA, and with playing time he will see that last 1/2 star. And for some reason when Gloria Buzău made their offer he not only went for it, when I declined it initially so did the locker room. In a case of “FM being FM” I am pretty sure I will see the full 180K I moved him for, but of course the moment he showed up at Gloria Buzău his value went to €425K – €1.4M. His leaving means one of the current youth players will get their chance.

Also, in looking to see who could replace him, I noticed something in the Romanian Squad rules: As long as a player is under contract, they can play. Yes, the League has a rule that “Only Players Registered for the Competition may play” but right above that? “Domestic Under-22 Players are eligible to play in ALL Matches.” And whats the vast majority of my squad going to be going forward? Domestic Under-22’s. 

Competition Registration Problems: Solved.

My Striker Problem: Also Solved, but not really. I am calling it a push.

This is Sabrin Sburlea. 5′ 8″ of UNAMBITIOUS 141 pounds who has potential. Will he ever see it. To quote him “Eh, maybe…”

His Attacking attributes are very good, and I suspect the ones in Orange are in double digits. His Decision making is also very good, and his Ball Control Attributes are average. Physically, for this level of football, I would say he’s above average except of course in jumping and strength. So why is he UNAMBITIOUS? If there’s one thing holding him back, that is it.


We needed a good start to the season, and we got it:

Sburlea scored in each of the first three games, and our first Liga II loss came against Gloria Buzău, although admittedly it could have been against Viitorul Cluj in the Cupa României Playoff.What stands out to me in all of these games is that with the exception of the Buzău and CSM Reşiţa matches, all of our losses were by 1 goal. Now, Liga II may not be a world class League, but with a couple of exceptions everyone is on a pretty level playing field I think, and that our team of mostly Younger players is doing well is a good sign. Of course, having a solid keeper like Rareş Murariu between the sticks also counts for a lot.

To be honest I forget what was happening in January and February, European Cup maybe (?), but we did not have a lot of Liga II games.

The only real heartbreak in this was the Quarter Final Loss to FC Argeş in the Cupa României. We had played them close all game, only to run out of gas in extra time. 

Iannis Malama, their young winger, was all over the field, and not only had the two goals, but both assists on the other goals, and a ton of dribbles and progressive passes. He’s the first positional player I have seen ever get a 10.0 in quite a while.

The Youth Intake

One thing I have to constantly remind myself is:

  • The Level of Football we play at is at best Mid. That is not neccesarily a bad thing.
  • The quality of person we have at HOYD and coaching is at best, above average at this point in time
  • While we have better than average facilities, if by some miracle we do get a ‘Copil Minune’, the odds of us holding onto him long term are nil.
  • The players we have coming in are being judged against who they are joining. 5 star potential is all well and good until you realize the best player on your team, the 5 sta one, may at best be 110 CA…our of 200.

That said, there were no surprises in this years Youth Intake, in fact I thought it was about middle of the road, until I saw the Personalities of the kids we recruited:

Of 16 Recruits, the Personality Breakdown is as follows:

  • 7 Unambitious, including our “Best” Recruit
  • 1 Each of the following:
    • Fickle
    • Low Determination
    • Low Self Belief (It’s been awhile since I have seen this one)
    • Fairly Sporting
    • Resilient
    • Fairly Professional
  • 3 Balanced

That’s…horrible. Now, being Youth Players on a Club that’s in a Youth Only save, they are going to see a lot of game time, and hopefully (and you know what they say about hope) may develop to get close to if not meet their projected PA. But Unambitious, Fickle, Low Determination and Self Belief is not the way to get there…

The Best

If it weren’t for his Personality, Vasile Mihăescu might be very good. As it stands, he may merely be good, but that’s OK. Physically he is already quite solid, like wise Defending where the only area he is lacking is Aggression. His Attacking Attributes are probably what you would expect for this level of football, average at best, although he has good Technique. His Passing, Crossing and First Touch are what will probably convince me to retrain him at DM, although I suspect his role Versatility may come in handy at some point.

If Florin Ilie can overcome his personality traits, I think he can be quite good for this level of Football. Physically speaking, he is quite solid, yes his strength is low but that will come up as he gets older (hopefully). And while 5′ 11″ is by no means short, for a D(C) it is on the small end, which is probably why his Aggression and Bravery are both high. He’s lacking where you would expect all young D(C)’s to lack, Possession attributes, and Finishing Attributes. He will most likely be a started in a few seasons.

Călin Rus looks to be one of those players who will be 16(16) at the end of the season, with a 6.7 rating, a couple of goals and assists, and maybe a player of the match. He can play a number of positions, which makes him valuable in that regard, but we will have to track his progression the next couple of years to see how he grows. 

William Brădău is supposed to be a striker. But I can’t quite shake the feeling that all his red attributes are closer to 3 than they are to 7. He has ‘Advanced Forward’ written all over him, expect for you know, the positioning, Stamina, Work Rate, Determination, and his personality. Part of me says that if I were confident his passing, vision and positioning would come anything close to a 10 or better, I could retrain him as an AM(C), maybe an En Ganche, and use him that way, but I rarely play with an AM(C), and I don’t think William will have a lot of double digit attributes when all is said and done.


THE REST

I can’t put my finger on it exactly, but Ilie Brădău bothers me. It’s not that he’s already pretty decent Physically speaking, or that the rest of his attributes really aren’t all that bad considering his a 15 y/o kid at a club with better than decent facilities but only OK coaching, in a country that’s also just OK at producing ‘Good to Great’ talent. He has the potential, heck they all do, but something tell me that in every Youth Intake there’s one player who will look like Tarzan, and play like Jane, and I think he may be the one, I don’t know why though

Of the others, Stanislav Sporin has a good Physical foundation to build on, but his Attacking and Possession have to increase for him to even be a starter.

Andrei Codrea could also be a contributor at some point down the road as well if his Attacking and Possession attributes improve, but I suspect many of them are going to stay in the red, or that the ones I need him to improve won’t.

Eusebiu Voicu is probably the one from this group that is worth really keeping an eye on. 6′ 4″, 163 pounds at 15 (!) what sets him apart from the others is that in many of the areas where they are bad, he is merely average, which means his floor is higher than theirs, and he will be able to contribute sooner rather than later.  Add in that he can play any of the attacking midfield positions and he becomes even more valuable to the squad. In this years intake, I bet he will see the field more than others initially, the rest depends on development. 

As Youth Keepers go, nothing really stands out about Denis Sbenghea other than his reflexes and Handling. He is going to need a lot of playing time, but to be honest I am not sure if he can get it here, which means going out on loan. And if he disappoints there…

If Teofil Stoian had any sort of ‘Average” or better Personality, I think he could be one of the better players in this Intake. especially as he can player either side of the defensive backlines. That said, I think what we see of him now is what we will have in a couple of years as well.


So, the Liga II Playoff are the top 6 teams, and they play every other team twice. The teop 2 teams are automatically promoted to Liga I, 3rd and 4th Place go to the Liga I/ Liga II playoffs. Interestingly, because of how the rules work, you can finish 1st in the Playoffs, but not with the League Overall. 

We did OK until the Unrea Dej game, when a late penalty gave them the win, against Petrolul Ploesti the whole team did their best to lose, the average as like 6.4; we had 3 shots to their 10, we should have lost. We also should have lost to FC Argeş, but thanks to a 90th minute goal by Avrămescu we didn’t, we merely drew, which was enough for us to finish 4th in the Playoff group.

Our opponents were Politehnica Iași, who finished 12th in the league overall, but 7th in the Relegation Group. A Decent squad, with a couple of good players, they beat us at home 1-0. We needed some help to get by, and we did, in the form of Rareş Murariu

A Matiş goal answered their first goal, then Avrămescu scored to equalize the aggregate, and it was off to extra time. He scored again in the 98th minute, but Anghel equalized for Iași in the 105th minute, and it was off to PK’s. Turcoveanu kicked it right to a waiting Murariu, and then with their last chance Ilie kicked it wide and Murariu blocked it.

We are going to Liga I…

The squad as a whole was solid, there really weren’t any standouts:

Matiş’s 10 goals led the way, Sburlea also had 10, and Vlaicu had 5, butt he oddity to me anyways is Bassong’s 10 assists from the D(L) side. The Candian International was solid, but he’s also been making noise about moving on. There were a couple of surprises in the best XI:

Two of last years Intake, Niculcea and Simedru, became full time starters frankly because they were better than the other options I had at those positions, and both had very good seasons to improve on.

On the business side of things, we improved a little:

And financially we are doing very well:

The nice thing about a lot of players on Youth Contracts or First contracts is that the payroll will most likely never exceed 60% of whats available, likewise as we aren’t spending any transfer money, there’s not a lot to worry about there.

Our chances next season? Not good. We will definitely be in the Relegation Group. What we need to do is finish high enough that we aren’t part of the the automatic drop of the playoffs, and I don’t how possible that is. Another decent Youth Intake certainly wont hurt either.

And the fun keeps coming. Thanks for Reading!

The Kids Are Alright -Season 1

Laying the foundation, one brick at a time…

There are a couple of different ways to start a save in my opinion, but choosing which route to take when it’s your first day is dependent on one thing. That one thing however, is comprised of multiple parts, because why wouldn’t it be? And what is that one thing?

Finances.

You could be the biggest team in the world, yet your financial situation might so so bad that making wholesale changes might not be possible. And what goes into that financial equation? Club Reputation, Where you are, salary limits…Now, I understand the urge is great to come in, clear house, and hire the best talent you can, but what if the best talent you can hire is no better than, or possible even worse than, the people you just let go. So, my advice, in a long terms save, don’t make wholesale changes across the board right away. Pick and choose, because your immediate priority isn’t assembling the best coaching and back room staff you can, it’s avoiding relegation, or staying up, or getting promoted. Once you’ve achieved that goal, then you can start making bigger changes.

Lucky for me all I have do do is worry about the coaching staff. Unlucky for me, the ones I have are not good, but the spot’s I have to fill I think we can get some good suggestion for. An Assistant Coach, 2 Coaches and a Set Piece Coach later, our coaching staff it…well, bad, but not the worst:

AS HOYD’s go, Daniel Mahu Moisii is pretty decent for this level of Football:

I tend to be agnostic when it comes to formations, I know what I prefer, but I also know I am not going to try and fit a square peg into a round hole and play a high tempo high line gegenpressing when I don’t have the squad for it. But the squad is actually, and I am not sure why I am typing this, pretty decent, except in one position, Striker:

This is the senior squad, at the end of the season, because like a numpty I didn’t take one at the beginning of the season, but it’s a good mix of solid older players and youngsters with potential. 

Transfers I am a bit conflicted on this first season. The rules on the forum are that if your board brings in a player you have to sell him, but the game had already signed Răzvan Matiş, and try as I might, he didn’t want to be sold, and the board wouldn’t let me release him. I’ll try again next season. Emil Pancu was sold to FCSB, but they offered a loan back, and I took it. My logic on this is that he was already part of the squad, and wasn’t someone I actively went looking for, and he’s going to be leaving in six months, so I treated it like a pending transfer. 


The Pundits picked us to finish 16th. I think we can finish top half, with an outside chance of finishing top 6. That will get us to the Playoff, and after that who knows what could happen?

As you can see, we got off to a quick start, with 13 points out of our first seven league games. And we did it by using a concept I rarely play with: Strikerless. This was necessary, because we have no good options up top, and I am loathe to experiment to much the first season, especially with youngsters. So I ended up using this formation almost all season:

It was a pretty solid formation for us. We gave up 2 or more goals only three times the first half of the season, and won two of those games, one a 5-3 victory and the other a 3-2 victory. In fact, in my opinion the only let down the first half of the season was our performance in the Cupa României Betano. I attribute most of our struggle there to depth, because you can see in September in October, we had a lot of games, and as I am more concerned with staying up than winning the cup, for many of those games I played a fairly rotated side, but that gave the youngsters some playing time, and that’s not a bad thing either. I think we did a respectable job, even if we finished 5th in the Group:

After a winter break, the season started up again, and we finished strong, finding our way into 6th place, grabbing the last spot in the promotion group.

Before that kicks off though, we had the Youth Intake:

I’ll be honest, this intake is a bit confusing. My ‘Best’ candidate is Goran Simedru, a 3 star current 5 star Potential player who is UNAMBITIOUS? I can’t make sense of that.

The Best

In Addition to being Unambitious, Simedru is 5′ 9”, can’t pass, and is injury prone. Something tells me he’s not going to get much better than this…

Darius Niculcea is quick and pacy, with a good work rate as well. Skills wise he’s Average at passing and crossing, but I think with his personality he will have the ability to meet his potential. 

Octavian Ciobanu is probably good enough to start for us now. Physically not the best (but the stamina helps) he has good marking and tackling skills, is a good decision maker, and his technique isn’t too bad either. The fact he is also 5’9″ and has no bravery means he will most likely be the person crossing the ball, not jumping up in the scrum for it.

The Potentials

Tiberiu Alexandru may end up being the best player of the bunch. He will probably be the first too see a lot of playing time, because I have no idea how or if I can hold onto my current keeper. The only thing about Alexandru is his potential ability, but I think with a decent amount of game time he will improve quickly.

As a Defensive Mid, Milan Precupanu is already pretty decent, average defending attributes, Decision Making, Good Technique and Fitness. The injury proneness is a concern, but him being Fairly Professional should help his development.

From a Physical Point of View, Bogdan Stancu is already a pretty good Wingback for this level of competition. But the Unambitious personality is giving me chest pains, hopefully sticking him in a good mentoring group will help him grow out of that.

At first glance Ciprian Bălan doesn’t look like much. But look down, and you will see a 5’6″ Temperamental teenager who has good (13+ already) Technique, Passing and Flair, is very Brave (In a Fight in the Dog sort of way), and will most likely get good enough Physically to be a first teamer by the time he’s 18. If he can last that long.

Horea Ursan a bit…well, to be honest, if he does meet his 5 Star PA we won’t be able to keep him, and that’s fine, but something just seems…off. I can’t explain it, why would a 6’3″ 165 pound 16 year old who is Physically Solid, solid defensively and with OK Composure, Decision Making with an OK Personality send the negative waves? I don’t know, but I think the 5 star PA for him is a chimera…

Outside Looking In

Of the two ‘fringe’ players, Marius Marinescu has the best chance of being decent, and I say that not only because he is a Realist whose Flair, Off the Ball, Technique and First Touch are already decent, but when adding in the good Finishing and Determination, but because when you look at Robert Păunescu, while he is physically more gifted, Skills wise he is very, very lacking. I think he will not get much better than where his physicals are now, but by the time he’s ready for first team ball we need to see some improvement.


All things considered, not a bad youth intake. There are a couple of kids there with some potential to be full time first teamers for sure.

We did a very good job in the Playoffs:

What helped us was that everyone else was beating up on everyone else as well, and when it was all said and done we finished in 4th place, good enough to meet Universitatea Cluj in the Liga I/Liga II playoffs:

We did Well enough to hold them to a 1-1 draw the first game, but in the away game, their quality showed, and they beat us 4-2 on aggregate.

It was a very good season, one in which the team can be very proud in how they did. We stayed financially solid, we have a ton of payroll to work with, now is the time to jettison some of the backroom deadweight we have, and when I tell the boys (and they are mostly boys) I’m aiming for a midtable finish they all pitch a fit, I am placing too much on their shoulders.

Well, the good news is the offseason is only about 3 weeks long, and I see a lot of windsprints, burpees, and running up hills until they agree with me in our future.

But it is a good start.

Thanks for Reading!

The Kids Are Alright -Season 0

“Copiii sunt în regulă”

I like scouting. I like developing youth players, I like taking a clubs from the lower levels to the highest possible, and having fun on the way.

But what if we took away Scouting? What if we went youth only? In a country with a rich football history, with some interesting teams to compete against? And could we make it slightly harder on ourselves?

Why yes, yes we can!

First and foremost, these are the rules we are using for this save: 

https://community.sigames.com/forums/topic/578526-the-fm24-youth-academy-challenge/

As you can see, from one of the posts further down a user has kindly generated a spreadsheet about what countries these saves have been done in, and which were successful, and which weren’t.

What I did was load up the Random Spinning Wheel of Doom with all the countries that have been played but haven’t won, and spun.

I got Croatia. The save lasted four years before I was sacked. NK Karlovac 1919 didn’t get promoted the first year, the club went semi professional the next year, and when we did get promoted, the still refused to go semi pro, all the good players left, leaving me a roster full of potential to face the likes of Dinamo, Hajduk Split, Rijeka…It’s four years of FM I will never get back, and frankly I don’t want to. It was horrible. Very Horrible. My Therapists says it will be OK. Someday…

After a short break, I went back to the Random Spinning Wheel of Doom, deleted Croatia, and rolled again. This time it was Romania. I created a manager, vacationed a year, and thought, this will be fun, there are some pretty interesting teams down in Liga III that will make for a fun save and…Liga III isn’t playable?

PBKAC error? Bug? Feature? I am not sure. So I went up to the second Tier or Romanian Football, the Liga 2 Casa Pariurilor, to see what teams had been promoted, and lo and behold:

SSU Politehnica Timişoara, which is short for Societatea Sportivă Universitară Politehnica Timişoara.

Now, Eastern European Football has been…interesting since the fall of the Berlin Wall, and the trials and tribulations of the teams in the Liga Profesionistă de Fotbal make for some good reading. The club itself has had a bunch of different names, but its affiliation with one of Romania’s best Technical Schools has never changed, and the Institute remains the teams majority owner. You can read about the history of the club here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SSU_Politehnica_Timi%C8%99oara

But the club has a few things going it it’s favor. The coach is not one of them. Meet Marius Țepeș, no direct relation to Vlad:

No Coaching badges, no skills to speak of, but a well worn and highly notated copy of ‘Inverting the Pyramid’ in his messenger bag. In his favor though, the club is pretty well set up for this sort of challenge:

I am pretty sure the Youth Facilities and Recruitment are a byproduct of being affiliated with the school, IE “Valentin, I see you kick ball very well and are top student in Organic Chemistry. Have you thought about your future? Do you like the color purple?”

Now, with regards to the ‘Can we make it slightly harder on ourselves’ part I mentioned earlier, I use the Mustermann Skin. It’s Brilliant, I love it even if it doesn’t have numbers. But, taking a page from GIMN’s book, I’ve disabled the ‘Player Search’ and ‘Staff Search’ buttons on the Staff Page:

Because I am not scouting at all this save (happy thoughts, safe happy thoughts….) that’s not as big a deal as disabling the staff search button. This means I cannot go out and find the best coaches all over the world and bring them to the club, I have to reply on those who arerecommended during the course of the save.

The other thing I have done is change the attribute ranges. This is Milan Precupanu, you’ll meet him in full later:

Not too bad for a 15 year old DM, but when you consider the following attribute spread

  • 1-7 is Bad, in RED.
  • 8-12 is Average, in ORANGE.
  • 13-16 is Good, in BLUE.
  • 17-20 is Excellent, in GREEN.

It makes a bit more interesting to work with. This method also means I have to pay a little closer attention to how the improve over the course of the save via the Development -> Attributes section, as opposed to the spreadsheet method I have used in the past.

This is going to be a long save, and the first few seasons are going to go by quickly. I am positive we can get promoted and stay up no problem, the issue is going to be the quality of our intakes, and what we can do to influence that. 

Romania itself is interesting IMO, it’s got a very good game reputation, but it’s Youth Rating isn’t the highest:

And there are 26 other teams with a Facilities Rating at least as good as ours and better:

The club we are trying to emulate is FCV Farul Constanţa, the result of a merger between Gheoghe Hagi’s club Viitorul Constanţa and Ciprian Maricas Farul Constanţa, whose youth development is one of the best in Southeastern Europe. Not only have they been winning Liga 1 titles, they have been developing and selling some very good players, Louis Munteneau and Adrian Mazilu to name a couple. They’ve got money and European appearances to help, and if that wasn’t enough we also have the traditional Romanian powerhouses to face of with as well, FCBS, Craiova, Cluj…

We’ve out work cut out for us, but I feel confident about this one. More confident than I did about the Croatia save, that’s for sure. 

Up next, a look at the first seasons, as we try and build the foundation for future success.

Thanks for reading!

Shattered Sphere

This is not for Football Manager, this is for Battletech, another game I play(ed) back in the day. But I am posting this here because I found the map in a hard drive and figured I would post what I put on the forum here as well for those people who may not be on the forums. :-) This is all the back ground I dedicated to it.

https://www.mediafire.com/file_premium/g61negyksuhtszh/DavShatteredSphere.pdf/file

You have several polities that are capable of defending themselves, but successfully prosecuting a long term war (similar to what happened in the 1st Succession Wars) and the odd’s of one state subsuming another by force are slim to none. 

Instead rulers are now looking towards new alliances, either thru marriage or political machinations.   

The recent announcement of Heir Prince Erik of the Suns to Helen Trempeleau, the eldest daughter of Duke Trempleau of the Outremer Federation has sent shockwaves thru the Shattered Sphere. 

Lost in the noise was Archon Zara’s proposal to Duchess Monique II of the Tamar Domains, Archon Brian Bradford of the Arcturus Alliance, and First Minster Ivan Timoshenko of the Rim World Coalition to stop their fighting and form a Union of Federal States was well received.  Duke Giovanni Lestrade of Skye never acknowledged receipt of the proposal, rumor has it he is preparing the Isles to go after worlds in the Duchy of Stewart, whose current weakness is highlighted by the infighting between Regent Markus Stewart, ruling in the name of four year old Adrienne Stewart, and Baron Giorgi Stewart-Huntsmann of Lancaster, who lost the Regency when his brother appointed Markus in his will. 

Watching with an interested eye is Duke Kieran Stewart-Percy, whose mother Ariel was Markus Stewart’s younger sister, and who was stripped of all her titles, claims, and fortune by her father when she married Duke Kian Percy twenty five years ago.

It is assumed that if any collection of Shattered Sphere States were to merge and become and Inner Sphere Power House, it would be the Warring Clans of the Former Combine, or the former states that comprised the Capellan Confederation.

The death of Yuguchi Kurita at the hands of Snow Fire led to the Shadow War, with Miyogi Kurita and Roweena Kurita fighting to see who would become the new coordinator.  When Taragi Kurita also announced his intent to become Coordinator, several other claimants also stepped up, leading to several battles and skirmishes, which soon led to outright war.  Political marriages and ally building took place, as the Combine broke up into “The Kosen Suta” or the Tatakau Shizoku Jidai.  All the current leaders claim the title of Coordinator, and can claim blood lineage back to the Kurita Family.  The strongest claimant is Yakeru Kurita of the Clan Kurita, but recent fighting against the Skye Isles and an ill planned and executed offensive to try and take the Tamar Domain worlds ended with the Kurita military in shambles.

Warlord Suoh Hakashi-Kurita became ruler of the Hakashi Domains when his father was killed on New Ivaarsen, and focused his attention on punishing the Suns of Davion, threatening to land troops on New Avalon.  Lately though, he has been distracted, first by by Duke Alexander Sandoval of Robinson, whose fief has remained a thorn in Suoh’s side.  Alexander has declared the now remaining four worlds of Robinson to be “The New Masada”, and has launched several raids from the planet, forcing Suoh to call off his offensive and concentrate on holding his new worlds.

Suoh’s other main distraction has been Masamune Nakagona-Kurita, perhaps the most feared claimant to the Coordinators throne.  A bloodthirsty tyrant who is best known for taking advantage of others misfortune, when Suoh Kurita’s efforts against the Suns stalled, Masamune led the Galedon Nihonto on a lightening offensive from Bremond, taking nine planets in short order.  He also took Cassias, McGehee, and Igualada from his “cousin”.  Masamune’s most recent action on Fairfax has put his cold bloodedness at the forefront again.  The 1st and 3rd Hakashi Gunba, with a detachment from the 1st Sword of Light, were fighting the 19th Avalon Hussars and the 281st Battle Regiment of the Lexington Combat Group.  Masamune landed on planet with the 1st Galedon Nihonto and his Battalion of Akumu.  When the 281st outflanked the 3rd Hakashi and drove them towards Masamunes lines, the Hakashi troops called for help, and instead found themselves under fire from the Galedon troops.  It was only after they agreed to surrender to Masamune’s forces that they were allowed thru, only to fins themselves dispossessed and now held for ransom.  Those troops that tried fighting back either found themselves dead, or crucified on the front lines as a warning.  When Prince Callum withdrew the 19th Avalon and 281st to deal with the advances of the Hakashi and Nakagona elsewhere, Tai-Sa Toyatomi Minoru  challenged Masamune to a mech duel.  Masamune demurred, instead sending several of his Akumu against the Sword of Light commander, who killed or wounded them all, before broadcasting in the open that Masamune must be a coward, sending good men to die in his stead.  Nothing is known of the battle between the two, what is known is that Masamune’s Emporer was all but destroyed by the Tai-Sa’s Stalker, Masamune has new new bionic right arm, and the Tai-Sa’s head has a place of prominence behind his throne on Galedon.  Rumors that Masamune was close to losing until one of his Akuma broke the rules and fired into the Tai-sa’s mech from behind are unfounded.

The most unknown of the claimants is Duchess Tomoe Sato-Kurita, who recently ascended her fathers throne when he died after a short illness.  What is known is that her Uncle, Hideyoshi Sato, who was married to her mother Tara, who died when Tomoe was seven, also made a claim for the throne, was but defeated in battle by Tomoe, and given leave to commit Seppuku.  The youngest of the claimants at thirty one years old, she has shown herself to be a capable administrator and warrior, her changes to the bureaucracy an New Samarkand and Pesht have streamlined production and tax collection across the prefecture, and her forces gains against the Suns, taking Alpheratz, Banori, Rudolpho, Baliggora and Raldamax have opened several eyes, but the one thing that has brought her to the attention of the rest of that Shattered Sphere is her defeat of Tai-Sho Allen Nakagona and his 3rd Gakedon Nihonto on Sinope with her 1st Pesht Ikko-Ikki.  Not only did she completely destroy the Tai-sho’s forces, she sent the first cousin of Masamune back to Galedon in shame, where he was not only executed for his failure, but his immediate family as also imprisoned or sold into slavery.

The Asgard Republic is a “recent” Polity, having been formed in 2947 when Warlord Sigismund Shor-Kurita renounced all of his claims to the Throne on Luthien and instead proclaimed the Asgard Republic.  For the next ten or so years Prince Sigismund fought to maintain his new polities independence, fighting off several attacks by the Tamar Pact and Clan Kurita.  During the course of this fighting his family, including his heir Aaren, were killed by Kurita ISF agents.  Despondent, Sigismund withdrew from daily life, and if not for the work done by his Warlord Axl Larsen, the Asgard Republic would have collapsed.  Sigismund’s death left no claimant for the leadership of the Republic, but by popular demand, the Tai-shu was “elected” King, but instead demurred to the title of “Prince”, declaring that the Republic’s one and only King was Sigismund, who’s vision for the Rasalhague worlds was the one he intended to fill.  The next 33 years saw the Prince move the worlds away from the Combine influences they had, adopting the more Scandinavian of their heritages.  The one exception to this is the states religion, as the religious Doctrines of the former Combine and Christianity not only coexist, but are gradually becoming one.  Larsen and the rest of the KungsArmee, assisted by many Noble families, have made the Republic, strong, fierce, and independent.  While the KungsArmee does not have a lot of mech regiments, the Republic as a whole has some of, if not the best, conventional forces left in the Shattered Sphere, as evidenced by the fact it was purely conventional forces that drove the 3rd Tamar Talwar off Mozirje in 3016.

Last but not least is the region known as the ‘Kosen Suta”, or the Warring Stars.  These are planets around Luthien that have at one point or another belonged to several of the other clans, until the ealry 2920’s, when Hohiro Dalton of Xinyang declared his candidacy for the throne, and was joined by several coreward world, including Kagoshima and Albiero.  His candidacy was shortlived though, as in less than ten years infighting, backstabbing, deceit and defeat left “The New Combine” defeated, mostly by internal forces.  However, with most of the major ruling families in the region decimated by the fighting, and the other Clans in the area having their own problems to deal with, the former worlds fell into an unclaimed state, and since then several warlords have risen up in the region, declared their candidacy,  and then whither away.  Several units left behind have become ‘Ronin’ protecting their planet, or in some instances Mercenaries for hire for one clan to attack another with some sort of plausible deniability.  Recently though, a new banner has been raised, on Iruzun General Minobu Ashikaga has proclaimed the “Ryu Umarekawaru”, and has adherents from all the other clans flocking to Iruzun to take part.  Recently, on his own behalf Tai-Sai Piotr Chelabinsky took his 17th Hakashi Gunba to Irizun, and was soundly defeated.  More concerning is that at least a battalions worth of his unti stayed behind to join Ashikaga’s campaign.

Luthien is the Imperial Planet, claimed by all, but occupied by none.  There is a understanding, Tacit or otherwise, that only one person may ascend the throne after defeating all other claimants, be it on the field of battle or the field of politics.  Occasionally, when two or more leaders wish to meet in an area they know nothing will happen to them, they go to Luthien. 


The Primary reason for this is the Mushashi Miyamoto School of Sakusen.  The Otomo are the Coordinator’s handpicked bodyguards, and with several claimants to the throne, the commander of the Otomo at the time proclaimed he would not support anyone unless they had the support of everyone and would uphold the ideals of the Combine.  He was supported by many commanders and MechWarrior’s, the least of which was a cadre of teachers from Sun Zhang on New Samarkand who did not want to pledge their fealty to Taragi Kurita.  There, they took an oath to keep Luthien free from ‘foreign’ interference, proclaiming it the ‘Imperial Planet’, and defending it in the Coordinators name.  Given that they did not recognize any of the claimants, Luthien has become an oddity, a havily defended world claimed by everyone, and defended by a large force that does not answer to any of them, and indeed will fight them off if required.  The Miyamoto school attracts students from all over the former Combine Worlds that are interested in defending the planet awaiting the Coordinators return.  Entry into the school is very competitive, and very fierce, although those who fail often stay on the planet to participate in other ways.  They also act as the planets defense force, and given the amount of industry still on planet, Luthien has been attacked by warlords great and small in the past. Soundly defeating all of them.  While each graduating class of MMSS is less than 100 students, not all stay on Luthien, some leave to find service in other Armed Forces, and although some (Nakagona in particular) treat them as spies and either imprison or execute them accordingly, a soldier in any of the Clans wearing the Wakazashi and Katana with the MMSS seal on the hilt is always respected. 
There had always been questions as to the combat capabilies of the MMSS cadre, but those were put to rest in 2993, when the 30th Galedon Nihonto “Went Rouge”, fought across the Kosen Suta, to Luthien, where they raided several orbital warehouses.  They retreated back to Hachiman, where then Coordinator Nikolai  Nakagona-Kurita, Masamune’s father, welcomed them back and after “punishing” the commanders of the unit with early retirement, ignored the protests from the MMSS.  The 30th was based on Hachiman, and about six months after the 30th returned, the planet was attacked by at least three regiments of Mech’s and supporting conventional forces.  All of them bore the interlocking 5 Rings insignia of the MMSS, and in less than a month, they not only hunted down and destroyed the 30th Galedon Nihonto, they also destroyed Tanadi Computer complex in Masamori before leaving the planet.  When news reached Nikolai he vowed revenge, until he woke up one morning with the heads of all the commanders of the 30th, including those he had “retired”, arranged into 5 rings on Naginata at the foot of his bed.  This was the start of Nikolai’s descent into madness, and his eventual death at the hands of his son in 2999. 


“Imagine if you will a reunited Capellan Confederation, combining the willpower and economic might of the Duchy, the pragmatism of St. Ives, and the cunning of the Supremacy.  The Alliance couldn’t stand up to that, nor Stewart.  The Compact would be beaten back to Tauraus, and I dare say the flag of the Confederation could be planted as far as Summer, Algedi, Robinson and New Avalon.  That it why it must never happen.”

   From the Diary of Primus Xavier Cortes, July 10th, 2998

As the Shadow War in Combine space was still going on, House Davion found itself infighting as well.  Prince Michael wanted to be a Peacemaker, and refused to consider any actions against the Combine.  When MIIO reported the state of the Capellan Confederation Armed Forces, Micahel again demurred against action, leading his son and Heir Carl Davion to act on his own.  In early 2866, on his own authority he led three mech regiments and about 20 conventional regiments against New Hessen.

For many historians, this was the action that Shattered the Inner Sphere.

The battlefield injuries that seriously wounded Ilsa Liao in 2828 on Orbisonia left her in excruciating pain, and for all intents and purposes left her an invalid.  Inheriting a situation that would have tested even the most capable of rulers, Laurelli Liao found herself doing everything she could to stem the tide on two front’s, and although at the end of the day, while she won the battles, in the end she lost the Capellan Confederation.  After 32 years of rule, her death in battle was the catalyst, within 10 years the Confederation would be sundered.
Her son Daimar lasted all of three years on the Celestial throne, his assassination (purportedly at the hands of Angmar Liao, Otto’s Regent), led to some behind the scenes fighting behind those loyal to Angmar, those loyal to Otto, and those who could see the precarious position the Confederation was in and were aghast at the Liao families failure to do anything about it. While Angmar and Otto fought behind the scenes to take control, Gerhard von Hesse, was fighting a losing battle, and called for help.
Duke Jiguang Teng of Tikonov answered, sending the Chesterton Voltigeurs, whose arrival forced Carl to retreat back to Mira.  Upon his arrival, Carl’s Uncle Peter, Prime Marshal of the AFFS was to arrest him, and instead found himself accompanying Carl back to New Avalon to overthrow Michael.  Operation PENDRAGON had just launched when the Davion Civil War broke out, leading to chaos. 

After the AFFS had been ejected from New Hessen, Dukes Teng, Hesse, and Alois Hargreaves, Duke Chesterton, convened on Slocum to discuss what to do next.  During the conference, an attack by the newly formed House Immarra almost killed all three of them, only a desperate defense by the Chesterton Voltigeurs battalion of Mechs that were on planet saved all of them.  Although she denied any involvement, it is believed Angmar Liao sent the House troops to kill the leaders, in an effort to replace them with people loyal to her, and draw their support away from Otto.
Instead, six months later, the Duchy of Tikonov was proclaimed.

160 years later, the Grand Duchy of Tikonov-Chesterton finds itself surrounded by eight enemies, and a populace determined to hold them off at all costs.  The retaking of Chesterton in 2907 was a highlight of the new entity, the Stand at New Aragon in 2957 indicative of the Republic as a whole:  Willing to die to the last person to hold onto what they believe is theirs, and an economy set up to support that belief.  Economically speaking, the Grand Duchy is a military powerhouse, with Mech and conventional unit production greater the the Lyre Federation in real numbers.  But their yearly losses are higher than any other Shattered Sphere state as well, and there is hardly and civilian industry in the Republic, better than 85% of it is geared towards maintaining the Duchy’s military.  The military itself is one of the best in the Shattered Sphere, Duchy units have routinely beaten forces two and three times their size, the officer corps is good, their NCO corps the best in the Inner Sphere, and the fact that every adult over the age of 18 must serve at least four years active duty and then serve in their local militia until the age of 60 gives them an enormous manpower pool to draw from.  Equipping it though, has been a issue since the Founding.  As a result, the Duchy has had to do more with less more often than almost any other military in the Shattered Sphere, and a a result, they often pull of Operations that on paper should not work, repairs that should not happen, and win fights they have no hope of winning.   

While the Duchy Touman’s of the Tikonov Guards, Hussars, Cossacks, Voltigeurs, Armored Scouts  and are nominally assigned to one operations area, the Duchy’s ideal of “Odna natsiya, Odin Grazhdanin”,  that is “One Citizen, One Nation” is paramount.  A Person may be born on Liao, but they are a Citizen of the Duchy before they are a citizen of Liao.  This ideal, and the nations militaristic culture, has led to several instances where a world has been captured by an enemy, only to find itself embroiled in a full scale partisan war.  The best example of this is Caph.  Invaded by the Skye Isles in 2987, the planet was under defended at the time, and although the two Touman’s of the 7th Tikonov Hussars, and the planetary militia of almost 30 regiments fought well, they could not overcome the three regiments of Skye Rangers that had invaded.  The Toumans boosted off, and the militia disbanded, but six months later a low intensity guerilla war broke out, and for the next seven years Skye forces were rotated in and out to try and stamp out the rebellion.  Duchy mech units made several raids, meanwhile Skye Conventional forces often found themselves under siege, and sweeps into Caphs jungles, where the majority of the resistance were staged, often ended in disaster.  Things got worse when Nicolo Lestrade arrived with several picked regiments of Infantry, he started a terror campaign that was soon met with in kind retribution, and the capital of Aswan soon became a warzone.  The situation came to a head when Nichola was killed by by a Militia infantry group that had infiltrated the Rangers command bunker.  A General attack by the planets militia, included carefully hoarded tanks, artillery, and a companies worth of mechs, drove the 9th Skye off planet in less than a month.

By 3025 though, after 160 years of low and midgrade conflict, the Duchy may be at a breaking point.  Despite inflicting heavy losses on the invading Regulan forces, the 5th Duchy Voltigeurs were forced off Sorunda by the Regulans in 3023.  In 3024 the 5th Hakashi Gunba routed the 34th Cossacks of Errai, and the 1st Duchy Life Guards barely held off the Davion Heavy Guards on Marlette.  Intelligence says that Oriente troops are preparing to make another attack on Vanra, with Brigadier Vladimir Orloff proclaiming he will die before he retreats from his families ancestral home.  On Tikonov, General Silas Tukachevsky is doing all he can to prepare for the coming invasion, but the only reinforcements he can send at the moment are the Touman’s of the 1st Duchy Cadre, currently completing the training cycle on Outreach.

For the most part, the rulers of the Duchy have been pragmatic in their diplomacy, often playing one side against the others to good effect.  However, like the rest of the Shattered Sphere, the Duchy has been rocked by the announcement of Prince Erik and Duchess Trempleau impending nuptial’s on Terra.  While the marriage may be political in nature, the economics of the new polity are a reset for the region, and the Duchy is already hard pressed to defend what it has.  While Duke Giorgi Hesse-Hargreaves has sent out feelers, in particular to Chancellor Chien Liu of the St. Ives Confederation, he knows a marriage between his daughter Cordelia and Xiumin Liao is a political nonstarter due to the two realms cultural differences. 


Angmar Liao, Duchess of Liao and Regent for Otto Liao, can be accused of many things, and most of them are true.  What she can not be accused of though is inaction, and when the opportunity to kill Otto Liao arose, she struck, sending a handpicked unit of mechs and infantry to attack the young mans training group.  The unit would have suceeded in killing the young man, if not for Colonel Josip McPhee and the Red Lancers.  McPhee had been a Lancer almost 30 years, had risen to command the unit after Larelli had been killed while leading it, and thru sheer grit, charisma, and doggedness had held the unit together. As the Second Succession War carried on.   While not a fan of Daimar and then Angmar’s creation and patronage of the Warrior Houses, he knew that their battlefield acumen would be a welcome addition to the CCAF, but the more he saw of Angmars actions and undertakings, especially as Otto Liao came closer to assuming the Celestial Throne, the more he saw the writing on the wall.  The first crack came when Tikonov declared it’s Independence.  The second came when an anonymous source told Colonel McPhee of Angmar’s intentions.  He did not believe it, until orders came for his unit to stand down.  Instead, he mobilized them, combat dropped into the battle, saved Otto from certain death, and the spirited him away.  The next year was madness, as the Inner Sphere started to fall apart, the 3rd Succession War fracturing the political entities. 

The CCAF was in disarray, Agmar Liao declared herself Chancellor.  While she had nominal control of the Sarna Commonality, the rest of the Confederation was in flux, and Otto took the opportunity to declare himself Chancellor on St. Ives.  While many expected him to take control of the local forces in St. Ives and turn them towards Sian, the young Chancellor did the opposite.  Colonel McPhee found himself promoted to General, responsible for reorganizing the units that had declared themselves in support of Otto.  Otoo, realizing he would need help in retaking the Celestial throne, embarked on a hiring campaign.  With the Second Succession War ending, there were more than a few Mercenary units out there looking for a new home, new sources of income, and new found glory.  Otto promised all that and more.  Too many of them forgot to read the very fine print.  Over the next couple of years, while forces loyal to Angmar and Otto sparred, and fought Tikonov forces from time to time as well, Otto and Colonel McPhee prepared, and launched Operation ECLIPSE, against the Federated Suns, who were in disarray due to the Civil War. In less than 5 years, Otto forces had regained several planets, including Wernke/Talon, and had also defeated Tikonov forces trying to take Bell, and beaten back several uncoordinated attacks by Angmar’s forces.
His lasting legacy however, may be the Kathil Declaration, declaring that Capellan Forces would no longer target Jumpships and use weapons of mass destruction, a proclamation that was sent to all of the  rulers of the Inner Sphere.  While Tikonov and the Free Words announced their intentions to follow the Declaration, it wasn’t until Comstar announced it would impose a HPG shutdown on any nation deliberately attacking a jumpship that the other rulers agreed.
As the Inner Sphere Shattered, Otto made no overt move to try and take back Sian.  With his help and reforms, the St. Ives Confederation became a fairly stable political entity.  While there was occasional fighting between the descendants of Angmar and Otto (Overton in particular has changed hands numerous times), the closest the Confederation has come to falling apart was the Mercenaries revolt of 2957. 
Several units had signed on with Otto during the start of the 3rd Succession War, but in their haste had often overlooked some details.  Each unit was hired under specific terms, and if they broke those terms, the penalties could be very high.  In effect, many units became effectively House Troops, as contract breaches over what would be minor infractions forced units into penury or disbandment.  Things came to a head in 2957, when Ruff’s Riders, a Battalion sized unit, was sent to Milos to help the 5th st. Ives Lancers.  An offensive was planned,m the time agreed upon, but unknown to Colonel Ruff, Milos calendar had a quirk in that every 90 days, the clocks were rolled back an hour to account for the planets orbit around the star.  The plan was set to launch at 4AM, and at 4AM local time, the St. Ives troops launched their attack.  Colonel Ruff had been unaware of the time change, but when he realized what had happened he mobilized his troops and began to fight as well, in fact the delay allowed his unit to flank the defending Sarna Regulars and pin them in place while the 5th St. Ives hammered a battalion of them into scrap.  At the conclusion of the battle though, the local Confederation commander decalred the unit in breach of contract, and moved to arrest Colonel Ruff and his command staff.  Instead he found himself a prisoner of Colonel Ruff, who had had enough of the poor treatment by his employers.
Appearing a few weeks later at Kittery, the Ruff Rider’s landed, and acted like they were moving to a canton, when they were attacked by elements of the 3rd St. Ives Light Horse. Proclaiming his units innocence, and broadcasting what had happened, the Light Horse soon found themselves surrounded by element of nopt only the Ruff Rider’s, but two other mercenary units on planet, Diz’s Demons and Brocks Bastardz.  What followed over the next six months was Colonel Ruff leading his newfound allies on a trip from Kittery, to Spica, to Beid, back to Spica, to Weekapaug, and then landing on St. Ives.  The action of the Confederation units, especially the justification being used by the commander of the 5th to try and punish Ruff and his command, led to several other mercenary units in the Confederation either packing up and trying to leave, or digging in and daring Confederation troops to try and dig them out.
Instead of attacking anything on St. Ives, Ruff and the Council of Commanders invoked a Parlay, with Precentor St. Ives as their arbiter.  Forced to accept, Chancellor Taren Liao and select members of his command staff met.  After both sides made their cases, Precentor St. Ives declared that while technically the Ruff Rider’s were in breach, the St. Ives Confederation’s reaction went well over the line, and constituted a major breach in and of itself.  Chancellor Liao and his generals began to protest, until Precentor St. Ives stepped in and said that if the Confederation was unwilling to amend its contract practices, the MRB would declare all contracts St. Ives had with units null and void, and that HPG fee’s on the Confederation would be raised to cover the expenses, salaries, and other associated costs with the units since their arrival in the Confederation.  The unspoken threat was the if they did not agree, the Confederation would be Interdicted.  Taren agreed, somewhat reluctantly, and was somewhat surprised when every unit present offered to sign a new contract with the Confederation.  A few months later, every unit, including Ruff’s, were back at their posts.  While there were some behind the scenes attempts at retribution, most were stopped.  In 3007, when their contract was due for renewal, Ruff’s Rider’s were instead offered the opportunity to become a House Unit, which they did, becoming the 1st St. Ives Hussars.

Angmar Liao knew she needed to bolster her powerbase before she could go after Otto, but with the Sphere Shattering, there were quite a few moving pieces, and by the time she consolidated her power, it was too late militarily, economically, and mentally.  Angmar Liao slowly went insane, until her son Wei took control on an interim basis, then assuming control in 2894.  This control was further cemented during the Army Revolt of 2899, when several military commanders were accused of conspiring with Otto in an effort to overthrow Wei’s rulership.  Given that Otto was primarily involved with holding his own planets facing Sian and going after un- and underdefended Davion worlds, this doesn’t make a lot of sense, but then again few things in the Sphere do.  Rumors persist that there was a behind the scenes battle for Primacy between the Surpremacy military and Warrior Houses were well on their way to being “First Among Equals” in the SAF.  Not a lot has changed since the Sphere Shattered in the Supremacy, rulers since Wei have instead played a long game, using subterfuge and diplomacy to weaken and confuse their opponents.  In recent history though, the CCAF showed it’s military prowess when in 3007, after the Compact raided Grand Base, the CCAF responded by taking Holloway, Xieng Khouang, Menke and Victoria in short order.  Equally eye opening was that on Victoria, it was CCAF regular units, and not Warrior House Units, that routed the Compact Jaegers off planet.  There has been no news out of Sian regarding the recent Wedding announcement

Der Bär Wird Wieder Brüllen, A Recap & 10 Years later

As I usually do with my saves, I simmed ahead 10 years to see if the team and coaches that followed have continued to build upon the foundation I left. This is sometimes a very hit or miss proposition, especially when you tend to use a ‘non-standard’ formation that you have the squad for. One of my best examples of this was my FM17 save, where we won multiple Champions Leagues and Ligue 1’s as USL Dunkerque using a 3-4-1-2, and after I retired the next coaches tried using a 4-2-3-1 and didn’t have any of the success I did. 

Seeing as how my last formation was a 4-1DM-1-3-1, I am slightly concerned.

In Dynamo’s case, they have hired some coaches that have had some good results, but have not come close to what we accomplished:

The Multiple League wins are nice, but the lack of European success is, to be frank, galling, so lets take a look at that.

  • 2041 – Lost in the Quarter Finals to Barcelona
  • 2042 – Lost in the Quarter Finals to Barcelona
  • 2043 – Lost in the Semi Final to Spurs, after beating Bayern in the Quarters
  • 2044 – Lost in the Quarter Finals to Milan
  • 2045 – Lost in the Quarter Finals to Athletico Madrid
  • 2046 – Lost in the Round of 16 to RB Leipzig
  • 2047 – Lost in the Finals to PSG
  • 2048 – Lost in the Semi-Finals to Chelsea
  • 2049 -Lost in the Semi-Finals to RB Leipzig
  • 2050 – Lost in the Quarter Finals to Sheffield United

Not a bad run, but it’s frustrating to come so close and not win it all again, and as we can see from the following, the club has stayed strong:

And I am not going to begrudge them a 4th place finish this season, they finished with 74 points, RB Leipzig finished with 79.

If there is one thing I am very proud of in this save, it’s the scouting. I will admit I hit quite bit more than I missed, but as I like scouting, for my longer, more detailed saves I tend to spend a lot of time with it, and for whatever reason, my FM23 Scouting setup worked very well in conjunction with my screen flow, and I was able to find a lot of good players early, Luca Montanaro as an example. I wanted to see how well I did, so I added a new coach and turned the editor on. In saves like this I always enable it, then the first thing I do when I get in the save is remove it from the toolbar so it’s not tempting me.

This is the current Dynamo Senior Squad. A note, not only am I using the Mustermann Skin, but I have altered the ranges as well, where:

  • Poor (RED) is 1-7
  • Average (ORANGE) is 8-12
  • Good (Blue) 13-16
  • Excellent (Green) 17-20

An older squad now, but still some familiar names:

  • Andrey Stefanov, my Bulgarian WB, 150 CA / 160 PA
  • Carlos Navarro, whose personality went from Driven to Professional, and has never has less than a 7.4 Average rating over the seasons, 178 CA / 180 PA.
  • Polat Kaya, my first good Youth Intake player, 179 CA / 185 PA
  • Constantin Ulreich, my second best Youth Intake player, 4 years after Polat, 158 CA / 164 PA.
  • Dragan Grčić, 13 seasons as the Dynamo Keeper, 173 CA / 174 PA.

And those are just the players still on the squad. If I go and take a look at the who’s who of players who have been thru the club it’s pretty wild:

2029/30 Transfers:
  • Luca Montanaro D(C), was found in Serie C, and I signed him for €400K ‘In’ this save, with the expectations he wasn’t going to stay long. He stayed 2 Seasons before Leipzig activated his release clause, and ended up in Man City (AKA Dynamo B). When Nicholas retired in 2040 he was 180 CA / 180 PA.
  • Mbaye Fall (M/AM(R) is one of the first bricks in the ‘Find a decent Scout for Africa and put them to work immediately. Signed on a Free, went to Bournemouth 3 years later for €40M, a very good winger 140 CA / 158 PA
2029/30 Transfers:
  • Dragan Pavlović (GK) was our first really good keepers (sorry Owusu, but RNG screwed you over this save). 172 CA / 176 PA.
  • Santiago Barros D(C) our first ‘Big Miss’. Never improved in training, was mediocre at best on the field, left Dynamo to play in the English Lower Leagues before ending up in Ireland. In 2040 he was 81 CA / 180 PA. One of FM’s mysteries… 
  • José Luís Gomes (Striker) was my first ‘Wonderkid Striker’. 18 goals his 1st season, the next season he didn’t want to renegotiate his contract and went to Brentford on the cheap, €3.4M. Several solid seasons there led him to Stoke, and then Man United. 146 CA / 156 PA.
2030/31 Transfers:
  • Christopher Essomba (D(L), my next West African Wonderkid. Signed on a Free, in 2040 was in Liverpool after stops in Milan, Monaco, Villareal and BvB. 148 CA / 155 PA.
  • Alexandar Petrov (Striker), my Gomes replacement had a somewhat similar career path. Played 1 1/2 seasons for us, then went to England, but instead of going to Brentford for €3.4 he ended up at Spurs for €74M. 164 CA / 174 PA.
2031/32 Transfers:
  • Jon Jiménez (DM/M(C)), our first ‘Big Buy’ at €17.75M. 4 Seasons with us before he moved to Angers for €47M, then to Dynamo B for €203M(!). 176 CA / 193 PA.
2032/33 Transfers:

We spent €81M, and while most were solid, veteran players, we took some risks, several of whom paid off, and some who didn’t.

  • Mantené Sountoura D(L), another African find, this time from MAli. Signed on a free, went to Porto and then to Athletico Madrid. 159 CA / 168 PA. Always Scout West Africa friends. Always.
  • Mirko Tulli (Striker), “Mercurial Mirko” popped up very early, an Italian wonderkid picked up by Inter from Cremonese who never cracked the starting lineup but avoided signing with the bigger teams. We had him for less than a calendar year, in for €14M, out for €21M to Monaco, where he spent a year, then back to Germany (he signed with Eintracht instead of us), and then to Tottenham, where he and Gomes are a pretty goos 1-2 up top. 171 CA/ 179 PA.
  • Jakov Popovic (GK) was signed to replace Pavlović. Six good seasons with us before going to Dynamo B for €52M, 160 CA / 169 PA.
  • Jeppe Vinterberg (M/AM(L)), after Barros, our next “Miss”, but in his case, it was injuries. Signed in Jan of 33, in Feb he had a hip injury and was out for 4 months. In ’34 he was out a total of 3 months with various heel and leg issues, in ’35 it was Groin strains, twisted knees and tight hammy’s. By ’35 it was obvious the injuries had done him in, his Physicals had declined enough that he was just ‘Decent’ IMO and we moved him on. He’s at Rangers in 2040, with a 134 CA / 166 PA. Which admittedly is good, but he could have been great IMO.
  • Carlos Tenorio (M(C)/AM (L/C) is one of, if not my favorite, players of the save. Signed for €25K, when he came back from his parent club he immediately stepped in at AM(C) and made his presence felt. An All around threat, he moved to Chelsea for €120M at the end of the ’39 Season. 181 CA / 181 PA.
2033/34 Transfers:

After spending so much money the previous season, we regressed a little in the league, but the good news was with the foundation of the club we had, and the recent signing, we were on solid footing. This however, was probably our worst year for signings in or Bundesliga era. 

  • Jean Cédric Baffouman (DM/M(C)/AM(C) an Ivory Coast product could never break into the starting lineup, and I thought I had better options, and he left for €145K to København, and recently moved to Werder in 2 Bundesliga. 128 CA / CA 158 PA.
  • Dylan Maclennan (Striker). Looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane. I thought I was getting a decent striker with potential, 32 goals 84 games is OK, but Attributes wise he was very comparable with other, better strikers who had played for us. And the problem was he would have a 3 or 4 goal game than disappear for 5-6 games. It was annoying to say the least, and I about fell out of the chair when I saw he was 145 CA / 159 PA.
2033/34 Transfers:

We signed 8 players this transfer window, and 5 of them were bangers.

  • Boris Castillo (D(C/R, DM, M(C) signed for €2M, then went to Dynamo B before moving to Nottingham Forrest. 144 CA / 152 PA
  • Santiago Viveros (AM (RLC), M(L/C), DM was poached from Bayer for the low fee 0f €2.1M, then moved to Hertha in 38/39 for €41.5M. A very good player for us until his attitude tanked, 147 CA/PA.
  • Angelo Bolzan (D(RC), another Italian Defender find, gave us 2 1/2 solid seasons before moving to Real Madrid for €76M. One of the games elites as it turns out, 196 CA / 198 PA. €76M seems cheap now…
  • Abdoulaye Traoré (AM(RLC), Striker) is yet another Ivorian Wonderkid, who spent a productive 2 1/2 seasons with use before moving to Juve for €26.5M. He’s been a quality player for them and with his 152 CA /159 PA that’s not surprising at all.
  • Osman Cengiz Buğdaycı (Striker, AM(R)) I was so thoroughly disgusted with Maclennan I went out of my way to find a replacement ASAP, and was able to sign Osman for a very nice fee of €13M. 2 1/12 seasons later (I’m sensing a theme here) he went to Man United for €75M. 179 CA / 180 PA.

2035/36 Transfers:

Another ‘Quiet’ window where we signed 3 players, but 2 of them are absolute world class.

  • Tim Schau (DM. M(C), AM(C)) we signed for €13.5 from QPR. A Season and a half later, Real Madrid signed him for €47.5, then in 39/40 Dynamo B signed him for €174M(!). 171 CA / 171 PA.
  • Lucas Curbelo (DM, M(LC), AM (LC), Striker) is a Uruguayan via Bulgaria, and we paid €7.5 for him. He went to Dynamo B in 38/39 for €83M. 186 CA / 187 PA.

2036/37 Transfers:

This was the year we ‘Broke the Bank’ for one player, but he was worth it IMO.

  • Andrey Stefanov was signed this window from Levski for €3.9. 158 CA / 161 PA.
  • Tatsuki Yoneyama (Striker) – More on him in a few.
  • Zori Eliyahu-Coracos (DM, M(C)) we signed for €41.5M from Norwich, where to be honest he had an underwhelming season. But he had two very good seasons for us before moving to Crystal Palace for €64M. 169 CA / 178 PA.
  • Junior Méyé (AM(RC), Striker) from Gabon. A steal at €135K when you consider he’s 135 CA / 157 PA at 21 y/o in 2040.
  • Casper Koch (D(RC), WB(R) I was looking at him to hold the fort down on the Defensive right, and that we poached him from RB Leipzig was very cool as well, but Wolves (who are a pretty good team in this game) offered us €30.5M and he jumped all over it. A 159 CA / 165 PA player.
  • Claudio Tessari (D (RC) from Italy, another world class find from the Italian Lower leagues (Serie B Palermo in this case) and a steal at €6.25M when you consider in 2040 he’s 171 CA / 180 PA.
2037/38 Transfers:
    • Sagi Ohayon (Striker) A bit of a journeyman career, but one of the players I signed to be part of my Striker rotation has been very good so far. 142 CA / 144 PA.
    • Ben Dahan (Striker, AM(C), M(C) More on him in a few.
    • Omar Mchedlishvili (D(RL), WB(R), M(R), AM(RC) A very good player who was so fed up with the coaches at Hertha he demanded a trade, and we were only too happy to oblige. Two very good season for us until Sheffield United came running. 157 CA/PA.
    2038/39 Transfers:
    • Dragan Grčić (GK) With Popovich moving to Dynamo B, and with the luck I’ve had signing keepers from this Region, Grčić certainly looked like he had a big future ahead of him, and he did. As we saw above, in 2050 he’s still with the club, but in 2040 he was a 159 CA / 174 PA player.
    • Alban Lüthi (D(C), DM, M9C), AM(C)) could find a spot at Liverpool (or the other teams he was at), but the 157 CA/PA player will have a future here.
    • Carlos Navarro (M(C), AM(C)) is one of the reasons I stuck with my 3 AM(C) formation. He was already a 4 star player when I signed him, he was a 5 star player when I retired, and with a 178 CA / 180 PA it’s easy to see why.
    • Pietro Rotunno (D(R)) had an interesting start to his career. My Italian scout found him at Renate, a Serie C team, and he let his contract run out. We signed him on a free, beating out a bunch of other teams, because his attributed looked pretty good, and on a free, why not? As you will see, he turned into a very good player, but in 2050 he’s a 123 CA / 171 PA Player.

    The 2039/40 transfer window was my last as head coach, so I am not too invested in the players, although there are a couple I want to look at.

    Marco Munoz, who we bought from PSG for €33M, had a series of loan spells, two good half seasons, then went to Benfica for €11.5M. With 136 CA / 173 PA I think this is a miss by the coaching staffs who followed mine. Hossam Yehia was a young Egyptian Keeper with an intriguing attribute set. With Grčić on the roster (and in danger of being poached), having a young talent on the bench could be handy. When we signed him he was 91 CA / 159 PA, in 2050 he’s 107 CA. Ole-Christian Berntsen was on an Amateur Contract at Arendal in Norway, and had Youth Caps. I took a flyer on him because hey, what’s to lose? The coaches following me found out, as he bounced around on loan spells (and had a good couple IMO) with only a few first team starts being moved to Norwich in 2046 for €5.25M. He’s a 140 CA player, who had a 180 PA ceiling. 

    Ben Dahan

    Signed for €3.5M in 2037, I found Ben thru Screenflow. I didn’t have him full scouted when I did, but holy cow, was I ever surprised. I went from a 4-2-2-2 Box to the 4-1-1-3-1 to get him on the field, and boy howdy, did he ever perform. He was one of the players I wanted to follow up on after retirement and simming forward, and I am glad I did. This is Ben at 30 years old. This was his 2nd Season at Athletico Madrid, he moved for €107M.

    Remember, because I modified my attribute range, those Green Circles are all 17 or better.

    This is his career so far. What isn’t included, and this is frustrating, are his International numbers as well:

    As an example, in 2045/46 he had 22 goals and 19 assists across all competitions. In 2046/47 it was 19 and 18. In 47/48 it was 26 and 21.

    He is the 3rd 200 PA player I’ve found thru scouting in six years of FM. Part of me wishes I had found him ten years earlier, but had I done that, he’d have been playing for Dynamo B by 2030.

    Tatsuke Yoneyama

    Signed for €2.3M from Kobe Leone in 2036/37, Tatsuke had 5 Seasons at Dynamo, before being signed in the 2041/42 season for €201M by Dynamo B. I am reasonably sure had I remained he would have stayed in Berlin for the rest of his career. As it stands, he’s had a pretty good one:

    A 187 CA / 189 PA Striker. Although if I am being honest in the 2043/44 season Dahan started at Striker and made the best XI with 26 goals, 10 assists and a 7.37 rating. Dahan and Yoneyama up top? in something like a 3-4-1-2…Hrrm…


    This was a fun save, this was my sort of save, taking a club that’s in the lower leagues and trying to bring them to the top. I wanted to do something different as well, some storytelling to help drive the narrative along, and I think for the most part I succeeded. Eventually though, the game was getting rough to play. Not because we kept on winning (which we weren’t), not because we kept getting the best players (Which we didn’t), but because I was spending way to much time fighting the board. 

    From the beginning it seems as if I was constantly at loggerheads with them, sure getting promoted out first season was unexpected but then going €20M+ in debt to get a new stadium built while trying to stave off relegation? It took me an inordinate amount of begging to get facilities upgrades, coaches and scouts expanded. For about 10 years our only affiliate was a RegionalLiga team so bad none of my players wanted to go there, and the two years I had a loan manager were the worst because he was constantly screwing me out of deals. It took me threatening to quit my job to get an affiliate, a good one in Heidenheim, and to get youth recruitment expanded. In the real world I would have quit much sooner, as it was the goals of the save were met: Win the Bundesliga, and Win the Champions League. It was a very good save, and very fun save, and I cannot thank everyone enough for following along.

    Up next, something a little different for me, 2024 being the year of change and all that. Watch this Space!